Abstract:Introduction: The amount of data generated by original research is growing exponentially. Publicly releasing them is recommended to comply with the Open Science principles. However, data collected from human participants cannot be released as-is without raising privacy concerns. Fully synthetic data represent a promising answer to this challenge. This approach is explored by the French Centre de Recherche en {É}pid{é}miologie et Sant{é} des Populations in the form of a synthetic data generation framework based on Classification and Regression Trees and an original distance-based filtering. The goal of this work was to develop a refined version of this framework and to assess its risk-utility profile with empirical and formal tools, including novel ones developed for the purpose of this evaluation.Materials and Methods: Our synthesis framework consists of four successive steps, each of which is designed to prevent specific risks of disclosure. We assessed its performance by applying two or more of these steps to a rich epidemiological dataset. Privacy and utility metrics were computed for each of the resulting synthetic datasets, which were further assessed using machine learning approaches.Results: Computed metrics showed a satisfactory level of protection against attribute disclosure attacks for each synthetic dataset, especially when the full framework was used. Membership disclosure attacks were formally prevented without significantly altering the data. Machine learning approaches showed a low risk of success for simulated singling out and linkability attacks. Distributional and inferential similarity with the original data were high with all datasets.Discussion: This work showed the technical feasibility of generating publicly releasable synthetic data using a multi-step framework. Formal and empirical tools specifically developed for this demonstration are a valuable contribution to this field. Further research should focus on the extension and validation of these tools, in an effort to specify the intrinsic qualities of alternative data synthesis methods.Conclusion: By successfully assessing the quality of data produced using a novel multi-step synthetic data generation framework, we showed the technical and conceptual soundness of the Open-CESP initiative, which seems ripe for full-scale implementation.

Identification Risks Evaluation of Partially Synthetic Data with the $\texttt{IdentificationRiskCalculation}$ R Package

Bayesian Estimation of Attribute Disclosure Risks in Synthetic Data with the $\texttt{AttributeRiskCalculation}$ R Package

Practical privacy metrics for synthetic data

Privacy risk from synthetic data: practical proposals

Risk-Efficient Bayesian Data Synthesis for Privacy Protection

Bayesian Data Synthesis and Disclosure Risk Quantification: An Application to the Consumer Expenditure Surveys

A density ratio framework for evaluating the utility of synthetic data

Data Privacy Protection and Utility Preservation through Bayesian Data Synthesis: A Case Study on Airbnb Listings

On integrating the number of synthetic data sets $m$ into the 'a priori' synthesis approach

Synthetic Census Microdata Generation: A Comparative Study of Synthesis Methods Examining the Trade-Off Between Disclosure Risk and Utility

Advancing microdata privacy protection: A review of synthetic data methods

Post-randomization for Controlling Identification Risk in Releasing Microdata from General Surveys

Privacy Risk Assessment for Synthetic Longitudinal Health Data

Using saturated count models for user-friendly synthesis of categorical data

Multiply-Imputed Synthetic Data: Advice to the Imputer

RiskBench: A Scenario-based Benchmark for Risk Identification

synth2: Synthetic control method with placebo tests, robustness test, and visualization

Synthetic data method to incorporate external information into a current study

Achilles' Heels: Vulnerable Record Identification in Synthetic Data Publishing

Statistical properties and privacy guarantees of an original distance-based fully synthetic data generation method

One Step to Efficient Synthetic Data