Abstract:Systematic descriptions of the underlying interaction rules that insects use to support group and swarm flight has the potential to contribute to mathematics, biology, and robotics, including aerial swarming under sensory and computational limitations. This study analyzes 1,000 trajectories of flying honeybees in crowded conditions approaching a moving stimulus and finds how during this stimulus, honeybees coordinate flight through pairwise interactions involving a novel three-zone decision-making process. The experimental setup consists of 3-D position reconstructions via a high speed camera system recording honeybee foragers returning to a hive entrance actuated to move robotically. The analysis consists of neighborhood identification through three methods (cross-correlation, distance threshold, and average distance threshold), which reveals the dominant interaction is pairwise. The individual leader-follower pair interactions are then tested against three regulation candidates: optic flow, relative velocity, and optical expansion rate, based on minimizing root mean square error. The results show that each follower demonstrates a three stage process involving a feedback rule change, linked by an intermediate observation/decision phase. During the initial ``lock'' phase, an insect maintains a consistent optical expansion rate until inter-agent distance closes to 10 cm. The regulation candidates then undergo large variations during a relatively long observation/decision zone, with 1.04 seconds being the average time in the decision zone. 79% of the paired insect entries into the decision zone result in subsequent re-engagement to track the same initial leader, while 21% result in disengagement from the group behavior. Visual regulation candidate comparison in the third stage indicates that upon re-engagement, the follower relative velocity is regulated to provide consistent velocity matching between agents. The third stage's velocity tracking is consistent with a closed-loop feedback proportional-integral (PI) controller regulating velocity tracking error. Across the insect population studied, the proportional gain remained showed minimal variability over individuals, a derivative gain was considered and found negligible, and the integral gain varied by individual. Collectively, these findings underscore the existence of an alternative swarm architecture, highlighting individual decision-making capabilities, feedback regulation target changes, and the presence of reactive, deliberative, and moderate (PI control) timescale interaction rules contained within aerial groups.

Pair Formation in Insect Swarms Driven by Adaptive Long-Range Interactions

Long-range acoustic interactions in insect swarms: an adaptive gravity model

Pairwise interactions, feedback rule changes, and deliberative decisions underlie honeybee inflight group coordination

The complex swarming dynamics of malaria mosquitoes emerges from simple minimally-interactive behavioral rules

Multisensory integration in Anopheles mosquito swarms: The role of visual and acoustic information in mate tracking and collision avoidance

Swarming and Pattern Formation due to Selective Attraction and Repulsion

BSwarm

Insect swarms can be bound together by repulsive forces

Collective Behaviour without Collective Order in Wild Swarms of Midges

Dynamics of mosquito swarms over a moving marker

Similarities between Insect Swarms and Isothermal Globular Clusters

Communication Model-Task Pairing in Artificial Swarm Design

Swarm Dynamics of Delayed Self-Propelled Particles with Non-Reciprocal Interactions

Collective Behavior Analysis of a Class of Social Foraging Swarms

Why insect swarms seem unduly complicated

Clustering through pair interactions in swimming zooplankton

Mosquitoes integrate visual and acoustic cues to mediate conspecific interactions in swarms

A Swarm Coherence Mechanism for Jellyfish

Collective Motion of A Class of Social Foraging Swarms

Interacting Swarm Sensing and Stabilization

Collective motion patterns of swarms with delay coupling: theory and experiment