Raman Investigation of the Ice Ic - Ice Ih Transformation

Milva Celli,Lorenzo Ulivi,Leonardo del Rosso

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2005.11814

2020-05-25

Abstract:Among the many ice polymorphs, ice I, that is present in nature at ambient pressure, occurs with two different structures, i.e. the stable hexagonal (Ih) or the metastable cubic (Ic) one. An accurate analysis of cubic ice Ic was missing until the recent discovery of an easy route to obtain it in a structurally pure form. Here we report a Raman spectroscopy study of the transformation of metastable ice Ic into the stable form Ih, by applying a very slow temperature ramp to the ice Ic samples initially at 150 K. The thermal behavior of the spectroscopic features originating from the lattice and OH-stretching vibrational modes was carefully measured, identifying the thermodynamic conditions of the Ic-Ih transition and the dynamics of both structure with remarkable accuracy. Moreover, the comparison of two determinations of the transformation kinetics allowed also to provide an estimation of the activation energy for this transformation process.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the kinetic and thermodynamic conditions for the transformation from cubic ice (ice Ic) to hexagonal ice (ice Ih). Specifically, the author analyzed in detail the structural changes and kinetic characteristics during this phase - change process through Raman spectroscopy technology and estimated the activation energy of the phase change.

### Main problems:
1. **Phase - change mechanism between cubic ice (ice Ic) and hexagonal ice (ice Ih)**:
- The author studied the Raman spectral changes of cubic ice at different temperatures by means of slow heating to reveal the specific process of its transformation to hexagonal ice.

2. **Kinetic parameters of the phase change**:
- By measuring the spectral changes at different temperatures, the author estimated the activation energy for the transformation from cubic ice to hexagonal ice, so as to better understand the kinetic mechanism of this phase change.

3. **Purity and stability of cubic ice**:
- The paper mentioned that the "cubic ice" obtained in previous experiments often contained stacking defects, which affected the accurate measurement of its structure and kinetic properties. Therefore, this study used a new method to prepare pure cubic ice, so that its phase - change behavior could be studied more precisely.

### Research background:
- The polymorphism of water ice has always been a hot issue in the field of physical chemistry. In particular, cubic ice (ice Ic), which is a metastable crystal in nature and usually exists only at low temperatures. Because its structure is very similar to that of hexagonal ice (ice Ih) but there are subtle differences, studying the phase change between the two is of great significance for understanding the behavior of water molecules at low temperatures.

### Experimental method:
- The author recorded the spectral changes of cubic ice samples during the slow heating process by Raman spectroscopy technology, focusing on the changes in lattice vibration modes and OH stretching vibration bands. Through the analysis of these spectral data, the author determined the temperature range of the phase change and estimated the activation energy of the phase change.

### Conclusion:
- The author found that the transformation from cubic ice to hexagonal ice mainly occurs in the temperature range of about 185 - 190 K. In addition, by comparing the experimental results at different heating rates, the author estimated that the average activation energy of the phase change is about 25 kJ/mol. This indicates that this phase change is a single - step process and the activation energy remains basically constant throughout the phase - change process.

### Formula summary:
- The calculation formula for the phase - change fraction $\alpha(T)$ is:
\[
\alpha(T) = 1 - \frac{R(T) - R_{\text{lin}}(T)}{\langle R(T_0) \rangle - R_{\text{lin}}(T_0)}
\]
where $R(T)$ is the intensity ratio at temperature $T$, $R_{\text{lin}}(T)$ is the linear extrapolation value of hexagonal ice, and $\langle R(T_0) \rangle$ is the average intensity ratio before the phase change.

- The calculation formula for the activation energy $E_\alpha$ is:
\[
E_\alpha = R \left( \frac{1}{T_2(\alpha)} - \frac{1}{T_1(\alpha)} \right)^{-1} \ln \left( \frac{(d\alpha_1/dt)_\alpha}{(d\alpha_2/dt)_\alpha} \right)
\]
where $T_1(\alpha)$ and $T_2(\alpha)$ are the temperatures at which the same phase - change fraction $\alpha$ is reached in Raman experiments and neutron diffraction experiments, respectively.

In conclusion, this paper studied in detail the phase - change process from cubic ice to hexagonal ice through Raman spectroscopy technology and provided new insights into the kinetic and thermodynamic characteristics of this phase change.