Comments on "An evaluation of hurricane superintensity in axisymmetric numerical models" by Raphaël Rousseau-Rizzi and Kerry Emanuel

Anastassia M. Makarieva,Andrei V. Nefiodov,Douglas Sheil,Antonio Donato Nobre,Alexander V. Chikunov,Günter Plunien,Bai-Lian Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1175/JAS-D-20-0156.1
2020-05-23
Abstract:In a recent paper Rousseau-Rizzi and Emanuel (2019) presented a derivation of an upper limit on maximum hurricane velocity at the surface. This derivation was based on a consideration of an infinitely narrow (differential) Carnot cycle with the warmer isotherm at the point of the maximum wind velocity. Here we show that this derivation neglected a significant term describing the kinetic energy change in the outflow. Additionally, we highlight the importance of a proper accounting for the power needed to lift liquid water. Finally, we provide a revision to the formula for surface fluxes of heat and momentum showing that, if we accept the assumptions adopted by Rousseau-Rizzi and Emanuel (2019), the resulting velocity estimate does not depend on the flux of sensible heat.
Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics,Fluid Dynamics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?