Abstract:We present a careful analysis of possible issues on the application of the self-excited Hawkes process to high-frequency financial data. We analyse a set of effects leading to significant biases in the estimation of the ‘criticality index’ n that quantifies the degree of endogeneity of how much past events trigger future events. We report the following model biases: (i) evidence of strong upward biases on the estimation of n when using power law memory kernels in the presence of outliers, (ii) strong effects on n resulting from the form of the regularization part of the power law kernel, (iii) strong edge effects on the estimated n when using power law kernels and (iv) the need for an exhaustive search of the absolute maximum of the log-likelihood function due to its complicated shape. Moreover, we demonstrate that the calibration of the Hawkes process on mixtures of pure Poisson process with changes of regime leads to completely spurious apparent critical values for the branching ratio (), while the true value is actually . More generally, regime shifts on the parameters of the Hawkes model and/or on the generating process itself are shown to systematically lead to a significant upward bias in the estimation of the branching ratio. We demonstrate the importance of the preparation of the high-frequency financial data, in particular: (a) the impact of overnight trading in the analysis of long-term trends, (b) intraday seasonality and detrending of the data and (c) vulnerability of the analysis to day-to-day non-stationarity and regime shifts. Special care is given to the decrease of quality of the timestamps of tick data due to latency and grouping of messages to packets by the stock exchange. Altogether, our careful exploration of the caveats of the calibration of the Hawkes process stresses the need for considering all the above issues before any conclusion can be sustained. In this respect, because the above effects are plaguing their analyses, the claim by Hardiman et al. [Eur. Phys. J. B – Cond. Matter Comp. Syst., 2013, 86, 442] that financial market has been continuously functioning at or close to criticality () cannot be supported. In contrast, our previous results on E-mini S&P 500 Futures Contracts and on major commodity future contracts are upheld.

Detecting discrete processes with the Epps effect

Critical reflexivity in financial markets: a Hawkes process analysis

Hawkes model for price and trades high-frequency dynamics

Hawkes processes in finance

A Metric Space for Point Process Excitations

Exponential Kernels with Latency in Hawkes Processes: Applications in Finance

Bayesian semi-parametric estimation of compound inhomogeneous Poisson processes for ultra-high frequency financial transaction data

A simple microstructure return model explaining microstructure noise and Epps effects

The statistical significance of multivariate Hawkes processes fitted to limit order book data

A point process model for rare event detection

Continuous-time Edge Modelling Using Non-Parametric Point Processes

Correlation emergence in two coupled simulated limit order books

Estimation of an Order Book Dependent Hawkes Process for Large Datasets

Tracking Dynamic Point Processes on Networks

Apparent criticality and calibration issues in the Hawkes self-excited point process model: application to high-frequency financial data

Epps Effect and the Signature of Short-Term Momentum Traders

An extension of Hawkes processes with ephemeral nearest effects

Spectral estimation of Hawkes processes from count data

Cox-Hawkes: doubly stochastic spatiotemporal Poisson processes

Parameter Estimation of Binned Hawkes Processes

Bayesian estimation of nonlinear Hawkes process