Simulation of laser induced retinal thermal injuries for non-uniform irradiance profiles and their evaluation according to the laser safety standard

Sebastian Kotzur,Siegfried Wahl,Annette Frederiksen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2555492
2020-05-19
Abstract:Laser systems emitting radiation in the visible and near infrared region are potentially hazardous for the retina of the human eye. This can result in irreparable injuries due to photomechanical, photothermal or photochemical light-tissue interactions. This investigation focuses on the photothermal interaction for which a computer model is used to simulate the thermal behavior of the retina and to predict the injury threshold values. The most important factors are the wavelength of the radiation, the exposure time and the irradiance profile on the retina. For performing safety evaluations and classifications the laser safety standard IEC 60825-1:2014 has to be considered. These evaluations are based on emission limits which depend on the same above mentioned factors. According to the IEC 60825-1:2014, non-uniform retinal images are treated by an image analysis where an averaged spot size is used. This averaged size is calculated by the extent of the irradiance profile along two orthogonal directions. Unlike the laser safety standard, the computer model predicts the injury thresholds for an irradiance profile on the retina without averaging the spot size. In this investigation, a broad variety of non-uniform retinal images is investigated with regard to the injury thresholds predicted by the computer model and to the classifications according to the laser safety standard.
Tissues and Organs,Optics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is the potential thermal damage risk to the human eye retina from laser radiation in the visible and near-infrared regions. Specifically, the paper focuses on predicting the threshold for retinal thermal damage under non-uniform irradiation distribution and the differences between these predictions and the evaluation results of laser safety standards (IEC 60825-1:2014). ### Main Research Content: 1. **Background**: - Radiation emitted by laser systems in the visible and near-infrared regions can cause irreversible damage to the human eye retina. - This damage is primarily caused by photothermal effects, involving factors such as the wavelength of the radiation, exposure time, and the irradiation distribution on the retina. - The laser safety standard IEC 60825-1:2014 is used to assess and classify the safety of laser systems, but its methods are mainly based on circular symmetric irradiation distribution. 2. **Research Objectives**: - To use computer models to simulate the threshold for retinal thermal damage under non-uniform irradiation distribution. - To evaluate the differences between these thresholds and the laser safety standard evaluation results, especially for non-uniform retinal images. 3. **Methods**: - Developed a three-dimensional computer model, improving the Seibersdorf Laboratories Model (SLM), to simulate retinal thermal damage under non-uniform irradiation distribution. - Considered top-hat irradiation distributions of elliptical and rectangular shapes. - Predicted damage thresholds by numerically solving the heat conduction equation and the Arrhenius equation. 4. **Results**: - Simulated different parameter sets (such as exposure time, retinal spot size) and obtained damage thresholds for elliptical and rectangular top-hat irradiation distributions. - Calculated the reduction factor (RF), which is the ratio of the damage threshold to the maximum permissible exposure (MPE). - Found that for elliptical top-hat irradiation distribution, the minimum reduction factor is approximately 1.6 to 1.8; for rectangular top-hat irradiation distribution, the minimum reduction factor is approximately 1.9 to 2.3. 5. **Conclusion**: - There are differences between the thresholds for retinal thermal damage under non-uniform irradiation distribution and the evaluation results of laser safety standards. - It is recommended to consider more detailed transfer functions and temperature behaviors when evaluating non-uniform irradiation distribution to improve the accuracy of the assessment. ### Summary: This paper studies the thresholds for retinal thermal damage under non-uniform irradiation distribution by developing and applying a three-dimensional computer model and compares these thresholds with laser safety standards. The results indicate that existing laser safety standards may be inadequate in handling non-uniform irradiation distribution and need further improvement.