Abstract:Despite the nonlinear nature of turbulence, there is evidence that part of the energy-transfer mechanisms sustaining wall turbulence can be ascribed to linear processes. The different scenarios stem from linear stability theory and comprise exponential instabilities, neutral modes, transient growth from non-normal operators, and parametric instabilities from temporal mean-flow variations, among others. These mechanisms, each potentially capable of leading to the observed turbulence structure, are rooted in theoretical and conceptual arguments. Whether the flow follows any or a combination of them remains elusive. Here, we evaluate the linear mechanisms responsible for the energy transfer from the streamwise-averaged mean-flow ($\bf U$) to the fluctuating velocities ($\bf u'$). We use cause-and-effect analysis based on interventions. This is achieved by direct numerical simulation of turbulent channel flows at low Reynolds number, in which the energy transfer from $\bf U$ to $\bf u'$ is constrained to preclude a targeted linear mechanism. We show that transient growth is sufficient for sustaining realistic wall turbulence. Self-sustaining turbulence persists when exponential instabilities, neutral modes, and parametric instabilities of the mean flow are suppressed. We further show that a key component of transient growth is the Orr/push-over mechanism induced by spanwise variations of the base flow. Finally, we demonstrate that an ensemble of simulations with various frozen-in-time $\bf U$ arranged so that only transient growth is active, can faithfully represent the energy transfer from $\bf U$ to $\bf u'$ as in realistic turbulence. Our approach provides direct cause-and-effect evaluation of the linear energy-injection mechanisms from $\bf U$ to $\bf u'$ in the fully nonlinear system and simplifies the conceptual model of self-sustaining wall turbulence.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the role of linear mechanisms in the energy transfer of wall turbulence. Specifically, the author studied the energy transfer process from the streamwise mean flow $ \mathbf{U} $ to the fluctuating velocity $ \mathbf{u'} $ by directly numerically simulating the turbulent channel flow at low Reynolds numbers. To achieve this goal, the author designed a series of numerical experiments. In these experiments, the energy transfer from the mean flow to the fluctuating velocity through different linear mechanisms was suppressed by minimally modifying the Navier - Stokes equations. ### Main problems 1. **The role of linear mechanisms in wall turbulence**: - The paper explored various mechanisms proposed in linear stability theory, such as exponential instability, neutral modes, transient growth caused by non - normal operators, and parametric instability caused by time - averaged flow changes, etc., to see whether these mechanisms can explain the maintenance of wall turbulence. - The author paid special attention to the transient growth mechanism, that is, the growth of perturbations within a certain period of time due to the non - normality of the linear operator. Whether this mechanism is sufficient to maintain the actual wall turbulence. 2. **The effectiveness of the transient growth mechanism**: - The author verified through numerical experiments whether the transient growth mechanism can still maintain self - sustaining wall turbulence in the absence of other linear mechanisms (such as exponential instability, neutral modes, and parametric instability). - The experimental results show that the transient growth mechanism is indeed sufficient to maintain the real - world wall turbulence, and the base - flow change of the spanwise fluctuations is a key component of the transient growth. ### Methods - **Numerical simulation**: The author used the direct numerical simulation (DNS) method to simulate the turbulent channel flow at low Reynolds numbers. - **Energy transfer constraint**: By modifying the Navier - Stokes equations, the energy transfer from the mean flow $ \mathbf{U} $ to the fluctuating velocity $ \mathbf{u'} $ was restricted, thereby suppressing specific linear mechanisms. - **Causal analysis**: By changing the intervening variables (i.e., energy transfer mechanisms) and observing the changes in the effect variables (i.e., turbulence characteristics), the roles of different linear mechanisms were evaluated. ### Conclusions - **The dominant role of the transient growth mechanism**: The research shows that the transient growth mechanism is the key to maintaining wall turbulence. Even when other linear mechanisms are suppressed, the transient growth can still maintain self - sustaining wall turbulence. - **Base - flow change of spanwise fluctuations**: The base - flow change of spanwise fluctuations (especially the Orr/push - over mechanism caused by spanwise fluctuations) is an important component of the transient growth. - **Simplified conceptual model**: The method proposed by the author provides a direct causal evaluation of the linear energy injection mechanism and simplifies the conceptual model of self - sustaining wall turbulence. ### Formulas - **Equation of motion**: \[ \frac{\partial \mathbf{u'}}{\partial t} = \mathbf{L}(\mathbf{U}) \mathbf{u'} + \mathbf{N}(\mathbf{u'}) \] where $ \mathbf{L}(\mathbf{U}) $ represents the linear term and $ \mathbf{N}(\mathbf{u'}) $ represents the nonlinear term. - **Transient growth**: - The transient growth mechanism can be described by the growth of perturbations within a certain period of time caused by the non - normal operator $ \mathbf{L}(\mathbf{U}) $. ### Summary This paper, through systematic numerical experiments and causal analysis, proved the importance of the transient growth mechanism in wall turbulence and provided a new perspective for understanding the maintenance mechanism of wall turbulence.

Cause-and-effect of linear mechanisms sustaining wall turbulence

Nonlinear mechanism of the self-sustaining process in the buffer and logarithmic layer of wall-bounded flows

Investigating nonlinearity in wall turbulence: regenerative versus parametric mechanisms

Wall-attached structures of velocity fluctuations in a turbulent boundary layer

Characteristic scales of Townsend's wall attached eddies

Are the dynamics of wall turbulence in minimal channels and larger domain channels equivalent? A graph-theoretic approach

Modal decomposition of nonlinear interactions in wall turbulence

Predicting structural and statistical features of wall turbulence

Spectral analysis of the budget equation in turbulent channel flows at high Reynolds number

Statistical state dynamics-based study of the stability of the mean statistical state of wall-bounded turbulence

Self-sustaining processes at all scales in wall-bounded turbulent shear flows

Structure and energy transfer in homogeneous turbulence below a free surface

Statistical structure of self-sustaining attached eddies in turbulent channel flow

Large-scale coherent structures in turbulent channel flow: a detuned instability of wall streaks

A minimal model of self-sustaining turbulence

Model for transitional turbulence in a planar shear flow

Causal features in turbulent channel flow

Self-sustaining process of minimal attached eddies in turbulent channel flow

The Role of Normal and Non-Normal Contributions to Enstrophy Production in the Near-Wall Region of a Turbulent Channel Flow

On the Structure of Streamwise Wall-Shear Stress Fluctuations in Turbulent Channel Flows