Taylor's law in innovation processes

F. Tria,I. Crimaldi,G. Aletti,V. D. P. Servedio
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/e22050573
2020-05-01
Abstract:Taylor's law quantifies the scaling properties of the fluctuations of the number of innovations occurring in open systems. Urn based modelling schemes have already proven to be effective in modelling this complex behaviour. Here, we present analytical estimations of Taylor's law exponents in such models, by leveraging on their representation in terms of triangular urn models. We also highlight the correspondence of these models with Poisson-Dirichlet processes and demonstrate how a non-trivial Taylor's law exponent is a kind of universal feature in systems related to human activities. We base this result on the analysis of four collections of data generated by human activity: (i) written language (from a Gutenberg corpus); (ii) a n online music website (<a class="link-external link-http" href="http://Last.fm" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>); (iii) Twitter hashtags; (iv) a on-line collaborative tagging system (<a class="link-external link-http" href="http://Del.icio.us" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a>). While Taylor's law observed in the last two datasets agrees with the plain model predictions, we need to introduce a generalization to fully characterize the behaviour of the first two datasets, where temporal correlations are possibly more relevant. We suggest that Taylor's law is a fundamental complement to Zipf's and Heaps' laws in unveiling the complex dynamical processes underlying the evolution of systems featuring innovation.
Physics and Society
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore Taylor's law in the innovation process. Specifically, the authors focus on the scaling properties of the fluctuation in the number of innovations in open systems and study this complex behavior through an "urn - based" modeling scheme. The main objectives of the paper are: 1. **Analysis and Prediction**: By analyzing four datasets generated by human activities (written language, online music websites, Twitter hashtags, online collaborative tagging systems), which cover multiple aspects from natural languages to the ways humans listen to music and the interactions in online collaborative systems, it provides an analytical estimate of the Taylor's law exponent. 2. **Model Extension**: Propose and verify two mechanisms to explain the phenomenon that the Taylor's law exponent observed in the actual datasets is greater than 1, which cannot be fully explained by the basic model. These two mechanisms are: - Quenched randomness of parameters: That is, each instance (such as each book) can be regarded as an instance of a random process in which a parameter is drawn from a given probability distribution, and these parameters remain fixed throughout the sequence generation process. - Urn model with semantic triggering: Used to explain the aggregation phenomenon when new things emerge. 3. **Combination of Theory and Empirical Evidence**: Through the comparison between theoretical analysis and empirical data, explore Taylor's law as a fundamental supplement to revealing the complex dynamic processes in innovation systems. Together with Zipf's law and Heaps' law, they jointly describe the statistical characteristics of innovation systems. Through these efforts, the paper aims to provide new perspectives and tools for understanding the statistical laws in the innovation process, especially how to capture and explain these laws through mathematical models. This not only contributes to theoretical understanding but also provides possible methodological support for practical applications.