Public Health Policy: COVID-19 Epidemic and SEIR Model with Asymptomatic Viral Carriers

Weijie Pang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2004.06311

2020-04-14

Abstract:We measure the effect of different public health regulations to the spread of COVID-19, based on a SEIRA model -- a SEIR model including asymptomatic transmissions. The cumulative confirmed cases and death show nonlinear positive relationship with the value of asymptomatic rate. Based on this model, we analyze the inhibit effects to COVID-19 of three types of public health policies, i.e. isolation of laboratory confirmed cases, general personal protection and quarantine (lock-down). The simulations conclude that the isolation display limited effects to the asymptomatic viral carriers. The general personal protection and quarantine perform similar effects when the their percentages of participants are same. When the total proportion of asymptomatic, mild symptomatic and neglected patients is 40%, only depends on isolation policy may lead to an additional 75% infections, compared with general personal protection or quarantine with an efficiency 80%. At end, we provide seven recommendations of public health intervention before and during an aerial transmitted epidemic (COVID-19).

Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to solve the problem of how to control the spread of COVID - 19 through different public health policies. Specifically, based on an improved SEIR model (called the SEIRA model), which includes the impact of asymptomatic infected people, the author evaluates the effects of three major public health intervention measures:

1. **Isolation of confirmed patients**: Self - isolation of patients with laboratory - confirmed diagnosis.
2. **General personal protection**: Such as wearing masks, washing hands frequently, and maintaining social distance, etc.
3. **Lockdown (quarantine)**: Lockdown measures at the provincial or national level.

In addition, the paper also analyzes the impact of the asymptomatic infection rate on the epidemic spread and simulates the effects of different policies under different asymptomatic infection rates. The study found that relying solely on the isolation policy for confirmed patients has limited effectiveness for asymptomatic infected people, while general personal protection and lockdown measures show similar effects at the same participation rate. When the proportion of total asymptomatic, mild - symptom, and unnoticed patients is 40%, relying solely on the isolation policy may lead to an additional 75% of infections. In contrast, general personal protection or lockdown measures with 80% efficiency can better control the epidemic.

### Model and method

The author uses an extended SEIR model (SEIRA model), in which the asymptomatic infected group (E) is introduced. The model equations are as follows:

\[
\frac{dS(t)}{dt}=-\alpha_I S(t)I(t)-\alpha_E\beta_E S(t)E(t)
\]
\[
\frac{dE(t)}{dt}=\alpha_I S(t)I(t)+\alpha_E\beta_E S(t)E(t)-\beta I(t)-\mu_E\beta_E E(t)
\]
\[
\frac{dI(t)}{dt}=\beta I(t)-\gamma I(t)-\mu_I I(t)
\]
\[
\frac{dR(t)}{dt}=\gamma I(t)
\]
\[
\frac{dD(t)}{dt}=\mu_I I(t)+\mu_E\beta_E E(t)
\]

where:
- \(S(t)\): Susceptible population
- \(E(t)\): Exposed but not yet diagnosed population
- \(I(t)\): Laboratory - confirmed infected people
- \(R(t)\): Recovered people (immune to COVID - 19)
- \(D(t)\): Number of deaths
- \(\alpha_I\) and \(\alpha_E\): Represent the exposure rates of the susceptible population to symptomatic and asymptomatic infected people respectively
- \(\beta\): Probability of infection in the exposed population
- \(\beta_I\) and \(\beta_E\): Represent the probabilities of symptomatic and asymptomatic infected people spreading the virus respectively
- \(\gamma\): Recovery rate of infected people
- \(\mu_I\) and \(\mu_E\): Represent the mortality rates of symptomatic and asymptomatic infected people respectively

### Conclusions and recommendations

The paper draws the following conclusions through simulation:

- The asymptomatic infection rate is a key parameter affecting the epidemic spread.
- When the asymptomatic infection rate exceeds 10%, the government should include general personal protection measures, especially wearing masks.
- For new viruses transmitted through droplets or aerosols, the government must take the following measures:
- Test all suspected cases with typical symptoms and their direct contacts.
- Estimate the proportion of asymptomatic infected people.
- Prepare sufficient N95 masks and other related equipment for medical staff.
- Prepare enough surgical masks for the public.
- Mandatorily isolate confirmed cases and all their contacts.
- Educate the public on correct personal protection methods in the early stage of the epidemic.
- Implement lockdown measures when the epidemic is inevitable.

These conclusions provide valuable references for dealing with similar airborne - transmitted diseases in the future.