Abstract:Chimera states arising in the classic Kuramoto system of two-dimensional phase coupled oscillators are transient but they are "long" transients in the sense that the average transient lifetime grows exponentially with the system size. For reasonably large systems, e.g., those consisting of a few hundreds oscillators, it is infeasible to numerically calculate or experimentally measure the average lifetime, so the chimera states are practically permanent. We find that small perturbations in the third dimension, which make system "slightly" three-dimensional, will reduce dramatically the transient lifetime. In particular, under such a perturbation, the practically infinite average transient lifetime will become extremely short, because it scales with the magnitude of the perturbation only logarithmically. Physically, this means that a reduction in the perturbation strength over many orders of magnitude, insofar as it is not zero, would result in only an incremental increase in the lifetime. The uncovered type of fragility of chimera states raises concerns about their observability in physical systems.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: After introducing a tiny three - dimensional perturbation, will the long - time transient chimera states originally exhibited in the two - dimensional system be significantly shortened, so that these states no longer appear as "virtually permanent" states in numerical calculations or physical experiments?
Specifically, the paper explores the following two main problems:
1. **Will transient chimera states become short - lived under high - dimensional perturbations?**
- The paper studies the Kuramoto model of two - dimensional rotational dynamics. In this model, chimera states are usually transient, but their average lifetime increases exponentially with the size of the system. For larger systems (for example, several hundred oscillators), this transient is actually infinitely long.
- The researchers propose that if a tiny three - dimensional perturbation is applied to the system, whether the lifetimes of these transient chimera states will be significantly shortened, so that they no longer appear as "virtually permanent" states in actual numerical calculations or physical experiments.
2. **The relationship between transient lifetime and perturbation intensity**
- The research finds that even if the perturbation intensity is very small, as long as it is not zero, the average transient lifetime of chimera states will become extremely short. Specifically, the transient lifetime is proportional to the logarithm of the perturbation intensity, that is, \(\langle \tau \rangle \sim -\ln \delta\).
- This means that even if the perturbation intensity is reduced by several orders of magnitude, the average transient lifetime will only increase slightly.
### Main findings
- **The fragility of chimera states**: The paper reveals a new fragility of chimera states. That is, after introducing a tiny three - dimensional perturbation, the previously long - existing chimera states will quickly disappear. This fragility casts doubt on the observability of chimera states in physical systems.
- **The logarithmic dependence of transient lifetime**: The research finds that the average transient lifetime of chimera states is proportional to the logarithm of the perturbation intensity, which indicates that even a very tiny perturbation will cause the rapid collapse of chimera states.
### Physical significance
- **The influence of tiny perturbations**: Even if the perturbation intensity is very small, as long as it is not zero, it will have a significant impact on the stability of chimera states. This means that in actual systems, due to unavoidable tiny perturbations, chimera states may be difficult to observe.
- **The influence of system size**: The research also finds that the size of the system has little impact on the transient lifetime of chimera states. Even if the system size increases, the transient lifetime will not be significantly extended, which is in sharp contrast to the behavior of chaotic transients in spatio - temporal dynamic systems.
### Conclusion
Through detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analyses, the paper reveals the fragility of chimera states under high - dimensional perturbations and provides a quantitative relationship between the transient lifetime of chimera states and the perturbation intensity. This finding is of great significance for understanding the chimera phenomenon in complex dynamic systems.