Zhongsheng Wei,Lei Tan,Guanqun Cai,Anthony E Phillips,Ivan da Silva,Mark G Kibble,Martin T Dove
Abstract:The counter-intuitive phenomenon of pressure-induced softening in materials is likely to be caused by the same dynamical behaviour that produces negative thermal expansion. Through a combination of molecular dynamics simulation on an idealised model and neutron diffraction at variable temperature and pressure, we show the existence of extraordinary and unprecedented pressure-induced softening in the negative thermal expansion material scandium fluoride, ScF$_3$, with values of the pressure-derivative of the bulk modulus $B$, $B^\prime = \partial B / \partial P$, reaching as low as $-40 \pm 1$.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to understand and explain the extreme pressure - induced softening phenomenon exhibited by scandium fluoride (ScF₃) under high - pressure conditions. Specifically, the paper explores the following points:
1. **Abnormal physical properties**: Materials usually become harder (i.e., the elastic modulus increases) under high pressure, but ScF₃ shows the opposite phenomenon - it becomes softer (i.e., the elastic modulus decreases) under high pressure. This phenomenon is called "pressure - induced softening".
2. **Negative thermal expansion mechanism**: ScF₃ is a negative thermal expansion material, that is, as the temperature rises, the volume of the material shrinks instead. The paper attempts to reveal the internal connection between this negative thermal expansion and pressure - induced softening.
3. **Extreme softening coefficient**: Through molecular dynamics simulations and neutron diffraction experiments, the researchers found that the pressure derivative of ScF₃, \( B'=\frac{\partial B}{\partial P} \), can reach a very low value (such as - 40 ± 1), which is unprecedented among known materials. Here, \( B \) is the bulk modulus, defined as \( B = - V\frac{\partial P}{\partial V} \), and \( B' \) describes the rate of change of \( B \) with pressure.
### Specific problem description
- **Background**: The paper mentions that in the past two decades, significant progress has been made in the research of negative thermal expansion materials, and a variety of materials with abnormal physical properties have been discovered. However, the phenomenon of pressure - induced softening is relatively rare, especially to such an extreme degree.
- **Objective**: By combining molecular dynamics simulations and neutron diffraction experiments, verify the structural changes of ScF₃ at different temperatures and pressures, and explain why it exhibits such extreme pressure - induced softening.
- **Methods**:
- **Molecular dynamics simulations**: Use a simplified model for simulations to predict the behavior of ScF₃ at different temperatures and pressures.
- **Neutron diffraction experiments**: Measure the crystal structure of ScF₃ at different temperatures and pressures and analyze the relationship between its volume and pressure.
- **Results**: The experimental results not only verified the extremely negative \( B' \) values predicted by the simulations but even exceeded the predicted values, reaching an unprecedented level.
### Conclusion
The paper shows the extreme pressure - induced softening phenomenon of ScF₃ under high - pressure conditions and reveals the association between this phenomenon and the negative thermal expansion mechanism. This extreme softening effect may be of great significance for designing new composite materials and regulating the thermodynamic behavior of materials.