Structure of Constrained Systems in Lagrangian Formalism and Degree of Freedom Count

Mohammad Javad Heidari,Ahmad Shirzad

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2003.13269

2020-03-30

Abstract:A detailed program is proposed in the Lagrangian formalism to investigate the dynamical behavior of a theory with singular Lagrangian. This program goes on, at different levels, parallel to the Hamiltonian analysis. In particular, we introduce the notions of first class and second class Lagrangian constraints. We show each sequence of first class constraints leads to a Neother identity and consequently to a gauge transformation. We give a general formula for counting the dynamical variables in Lagrangian formalism. As the main advantage of Lagrangian approach, we show the whole procedure can also be performed covariantly. Several examples are given to make our Lagrangian approach clear.

Classical Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to study the dynamical behavior of theories with singular Lagrangians in the Lagrangian formalism. Specifically, the paper proposes a detailed procedure to analyze the dynamical properties of constrained systems that exhibit singular properties in the Lagrangian formalism. The main contributions of the paper are as follows:

1. **Classification of Constraints**: The concepts of first - class and second - class Lagrangian constraints are introduced, and it is shown how each sequence of first - class constraints leads to Noether's theorem and the corresponding gauge transformation.
2. **Counting Degrees of Freedom**: A general formula is provided to calculate the number of dynamical variables in the Lagrangian formalism.
3. **Covariant Treatment**: It is shown that the whole process can be carried out in a covariant manner, which is a major advantage of the Lagrangian method.
4. **Case - study Analysis**: The application of the Lagrangian method is illustrated in detail through multiple examples, enabling readers to better understand this method.

### Abstract of the Paper
The paper proposes a detailed procedure for studying the dynamical behavior of theories with singular Lagrangians in the Lagrangian formalism. This procedure runs parallel to the Hamiltonian analysis at different levels. In particular, the paper introduces the concepts of first - class and second - class Lagrangian constraints and shows how each sequence of first - class constraints leads to Noether's theorem and the corresponding gauge transformation. The paper also provides a general formula to calculate the number of dynamical variables in the Lagrangian formalism and shows that the whole process can be carried out in a covariant manner. Through multiple examples, the paper illustrates the application of the Lagrangian method in detail.

### Main Structure
1. **Introduction**: The research background of constrained systems in the Hamiltonian framework and the advantages of the Lagrangian method are introduced.
2. **FPS Decomposition**: A detailed description is given of how to divide constraints into three categories at each consistency level: first - class, second - class, and undetermined constraints.
3. **Counting Degrees of Freedom**: The formula for calculating the number of dynamical variables in the Lagrangian formalism is derived.
4. **Case - study Analysis**: Through multiple simple and complex examples, the specific application of the Lagrangian method is demonstrated.
5. **Covariant Form**: The covariant treatment method in field theory is explored and illustrated through specific examples such as the Polyakov string, general relativity, and Yang - Mills theory.

### Key Formulas
- **Formula for Counting Degrees of Freedom**:
\[
D = P-(F.C + F)-\frac{1}{2}S.C
\]
where:
- \(P\) is the original number of degrees of freedom.
- \(F.C\) is the total number of first - class Lagrangian constraints.
- \(F\) is the number of gauge parameters.
- \(S.C\) is the total number of second - class Lagrangian constraints.

### Conclusion
Through detailed theoretical analysis and case - study verification, the paper demonstrates the effectiveness and superiority of the Lagrangian method in studying the dynamical behavior of constrained systems, especially in covariant treatment.