Spatiotemporal fluctuation scaling law and metapopulation modeling of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) and SARS outbreaks

Zhanshan Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2003.03714

2020-03-08

Abstract:We comparatively analyzed the spatiotemporal fluctuations of the 2019-novel coronavirus (COVID-19) and SARS outbreaks to understand their epidemiological characteristics. Methodologically, we introduced TPL (Taylor power law) to characterize their spatiotemporal heterogeneity/stability and Hubbell (2001) unified neutral theory of biodiversity (UNTB) [specifically Harris et al. (2015) HDP-MSN model (hierarchical Dirichlet process multi-site neutral model)] to approximate the metapopulation of coronavirus infections. First, TPL analysis suggested that the coronaviruses appear to have a specific heterogeneity/stability scaling parameter (TPL-b) slightly exceeding 2 for cumulative infections or exceeding 1 for daily incremental infections, suggesting their potentially chaotic, unstable outbreaks. Another TPL parameter (M0) (i.e., infection critical threshold) depends on virus kinds (COVID-19/SARS), time (disease-stages), space (regions) and public-health interventions (e.g., quarantines and mobility control). M0 measures the infection level, at which infections are random (Poisson distribution) and below which infections follow uniform distribution and may die off if M0 coincides or below the level of Allee effects. It was found that COVID-19 outbreak seems nearly twice more risky than SARS, and the lower infection threshold may be due to its lower lethality than SARS since lower fatality rates can facilitate the survival and spread of pathogen. Second, metacommunity UNTB neutrality testing seems appropriate for approximating metapopulation of coronavirus infections. Specifically, two parameters {\theta} and M, borrowed from neutral theory, may be used to assess the relative significance of infection through local contagion vs. infection through migration, both of which may depend on time, space, virus kinds, and particularly public-health interventions.

Populations and Evolution

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly include two aspects:

1. **Explore the spatio - temporal fluctuation laws of coronavirus (such as 2019 - nCoV or COVID - 19 and SARS) infections**:
- The authors introduce Taylor's Power Law (TPL) to characterize the heterogeneity or stability of these virus infections in time and space. Specifically, they analyze the spatio - temporal fluctuations of the cumulative number of COVID - 19 infections and the daily new infections, and find that these fluctuations follow a specific power - law relationship. For example, for the cumulative number of infections, the TPL parameter \( b \) slightly exceeds 2, while for the daily new infections, \( b \) exceeds 1, indicating that the outbreak of COVID - 19 may have "chaotic" and unstable characteristics.
- The paper also explores the critical threshold of infection \( M_0 \), that is, when the infection level is below this threshold, the infection may be randomly distributed or tend to be stable, and when it is above this threshold, the infection may become unstable. The value of \( M_0 \) depends on the virus type (such as COVID - 19 or SARS), time (disease stage), space (region), and public health interventions (such as isolation and mobility control).

2. **Evaluate the relative importance of local transmission and external migration in virus spread**:
- The authors adopt the HDP - MSN model in Hubbell's Unified Neutral Theory of Biodiversity (UNTB) to approximate the metapopulation dynamics of coronavirus infections. By estimating the key parameters in the model (such as the migration rate \( M \) and the local transmission rate \( \theta \)), the authors evaluate the relative importance of these two transmission mechanisms at different time and space scales.
- For example, for COVID - 19 infections within China, the importance of migratory spread is approximately 21 times that of local transmission, while globally, the two are roughly equally important. This indicates that in China, controlling the movement of people is crucial for suppressing the spread of the epidemic.

Through the above methods, the paper aims to reveal the epidemiological characteristics of the coronavirus outbreak and provide a scientific basis for epidemic prevention and control. In particular, the paper emphasizes the important role of controlling migration and implementing public health interventions in stabilizing the epidemic.