Giant magnetic exchange coupling in rhombus-shaped nanographenes with zigzag periphery

Shantanu Mishra,Xuelin Yao,Qiang Chen,Kristjan Eimre,Oliver Groening,Ricardo Ortiz,Marco Di Giovannantonio,Juan Carlos Sancho-Garcia,Joaquin Fernandez-Rossier,Carlo A. Pignedoli,Klaus Muellen,Pascal Ruffieux,Akimitsu Narita,Roman Fasel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41557-021-00678-2

2020-03-07

Abstract:Nanographenes with zigzag edges are predicted to manifest non-trivial pi-magnetism resulting from the interplay of hybridization of localized frontier states and Coulomb repulsion between valence electrons. This provides a chemically tunable platform to explore quantum magnetism at the nanoscale and opens avenues toward organic spintronics. The magnetic stability in nanographenes is thus far limited by the weak magnetic exchange coupling which remains below the room temperature thermal energy. Here, we report the synthesis of large rhombus-shaped nanographenes with zigzag periphery on gold and copper surfaces. Single-molecule scanning probe measurements unveil an emergent magnetic spin-singlet ground state with increasing nanographene size. The magnetic exchange coupling in the largest nanographene, determined by inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy, exceeds 100 meV or 1160 K, which outclasses most inorganic nanomaterials and remarkably survives on a metal electrode.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to achieve strong magnetic exchange coupling (MEC) in nanographenes with specific shapes and edge structures. Specifically, the researchers synthesized rhombic nanographenes with zig - zag edges and revealed the magnetic spin - singlet ground states that occur as these nanographenes increase in size through single - molecule scanning probe measurement techniques. In particular, for the largest nanographene, its magnetic exchange coupling strength exceeds 100 meV or 1160 K, which is far greater than most inorganic nanomaterials, and this property can be maintained even on metal electrodes.

### Research Background and Problems
1. **Exploration of Carbon - Based Magnetism**: Although ideal graphene is a non - magnetic semimetal, its derivative nanographenes are predicted to be able to exhibit magnetism. This magnetism is different from that in molecules and solids containing transition - metal atoms because unpaired electrons are mainly distributed in molecular π - orbitals rather than localized on transition - metal atoms.
2. **Challenges of Magnetic Exchange Coupling**: Previously, the magnetic stability in nanographenes was limited by weak magnetic exchange coupling, and this coupling strength was usually lower than the thermal energy at room temperature (about 25 meV).
3. **Importance of Zig - Zag Edges**: Nanographenes with zig - zag edges can significantly reduce the hybridization energy, thus potentially forming open - shell magnetic ground states.

### Research Objectives
- **Synthesis of Rhombic Nanographenes with Zig - Zag Edges**: The researchers prepared rhombic nanographenes with zig - zag edges through surface synthesis techniques. These nanographenes contain 4 and 5 benzene - ring units respectively.
- **Measurement of Magnetic Exchange Coupling Strength**: Through inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) measurement, the magnetic exchange coupling strength of these nanographenes was determined. In particular, in the largest nanographene, its MEC exceeds 100 meV, much higher than the thermal energy at room temperature.

### Main Findings
- **Magnetic Spin - Singlet Ground State**: As the size of the nanographene increases, its ground state changes from a closed - shell to an open - shell magnetic spin - singlet.
- **Strong Magnetic Exchange Coupling**: The magnetic exchange coupling strength of the largest nanographene (C70H22) reaches 102 meV, far exceeding most known transition - metal nanomagnets.
- **Room - Temperature Stability**: This strong magnetic exchange coupling can also be maintained on metal electrodes, providing the possibility for stable spintronics applications at room temperature.

### Significance
- **Combination of Theory and Experiment**: Through the combination of theoretical calculations and experimental measurements, it has been verified that nanographenes with zig - zag edges can achieve strong magnetic exchange coupling.
- **Future Application Prospects**: This finding provides a new approach for the development of carbon - based quantum magnetic materials and room - temperature spintronics devices.

### Formulas
- **Hubbard Model**:
\[
H_{\text{Hubbard}}=\sum_{\langle\alpha,\beta\rangle j,\sigma}-t_j c_{\alpha\sigma}^{\dagger} c_{\beta\sigma}+U\sum_{\alpha,\sigma} n_{\alpha\sigma}-U\sum_{\alpha} n_{\alpha\uparrow} n_{\alpha\downarrow}
\]
where \(c_{\alpha\sigma}^{\dagger}\) and \(c_{\beta\sigma}\) represent the creation and annihilation operators with spin selectivity (\(\sigma\in\{\uparrow,\downarrow\}\)) at sites \(\alpha\) and \(\beta\) respectively, \(t_j\) represents the nearest - neighbor, next - nearest - neighbor and third - nearest - neighbor hopping parameters, \(U\) represents the on - site Coulomb repulsion, and \(n_{\alpha\sigma}\) represents the number operator.

- **Electron Density**:
\[
\rho_{n,\sigma}(\vec{r})=\sum_i|a_{n,i,\sigma}|^2\varphi_{i,\sigma}(\vec{r})
\]