Complete and competitive financial markets in a complex world

Gianluca Cassese

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00780-021-00463-6

2021-03-16

Abstract:We investigate the possibility of completing financial markets in a model with no exogenous probability measure and market imperfections. A necessary and sufficient condition is obtained for such extension to be possible.

Mathematical Finance

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Partial Equilibrium and Market Completion

Ying Hu,Peter Imkeller,Matthias Mueller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s0219024905003098

2005-01-01

International Journal of Theoretical and Applied Finance

Abstract:We consider financial markets with agents exposed to an external source of risk which cannot be hedged through investments on the capital market alone. The sources of risk we think of may be weather and climate. Therefore we face a typical example of an incomplete financial market. We design a model of a market on which the external risk becomes tradable. In a first step we complete the market by introducing an extra security which valuates the external risk through a process parameter describing its market price. If this parameter is fixed, risk has a price and every agent can maximize the expected exponential utility with individual risk aversion obtained from his risk exposure on the one hand and his investment into the financial market consisting of an exogenous set of stocks and the insurance asset on the other hand. In the second step, the market price of risk parameter has to be determined by a partial equilibrium condition which just expresses the fact that in equilibrium the market is cleared of the second security. This choice of market price of risk is performed in the framework of nonlinear backwards stochastic differential equations.
Asset Pricing in an Imperfect World

Gianluca Cassese

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00199-016-0999-7

2014-10-24

Abstract:In a model with no given probability measure, we consider asset pricing in the presence of frictions and other imperfections and characterize the property of coherent pricing, a notion related to (but much weaker than) the no arbitrage property. We show that prices are coherent if and only if the set of pricing measures is non empty, i.e. if pricing by expectation is possible. We then obtain a decomposition of coherent prices highlighting the role of bubbles. Eventually we show that under very weak conditions the coherent pricing of options allows for a very clear representation which allows, as in Breeden and Litzenberger, to extract the implied probability.

Mathematical Finance,Pricing of Securities
Existence of financial equilibria in continuous time with potentially complete markets

Frank Riedel,Frederik Herzberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmateco.2013.07.001

IF: 0.747

2013-10-01

Journal of Mathematical Economics

Abstract:We prove that in smooth Markovian continuous-time economies with potentially complete asset markets, Radner equilibria with endogenously complete markets exist.

economics,social sciences, mathematical methods,mathematics, interdisciplinary applications
Financial equilibria in the semimartingale setting: complete markets and markets with withdrawal constraints

Gordan Zitkovic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0706.0462

2007-06-04

Abstract:Existence of stochastic financial equilibria giving rise to semimartingale asset prices is established under a general class of assumptions. These equilibria are expressed in real terms and span complete markets or markets with withdrawal <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://constraints.We" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> deal with random endowment density streams which admit jumps and general time-dependent utility functions on which only regularity conditions are imposed. As an integral part of the proof of the main result, we establish a novel characterization of semimartingale functions.

Pricing of Securities,Optimization and Control,Probability
Financial Entanglement: A Theory of Incomplete Integration, Leverage, Crashes, and Contagion

Nicolae Garleanu,Stavros Panageas,Jianfeng Yu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2313026

IF: 10.7

2015-01-01

American Economic Review

Abstract:We propose a unified model of limited market integration, asset-price determination, leveraging, and contagion. Investors and firms are located on a circle, and access to markets involves participation costs that increase with distance. Due to a complementarity between participation and leverage decisions, the equilibrium may exhibit diverse leverage and participation choices across investors, although investors are ex ante identical. Small changes in market-access costs can cause a change in the type of equilibrium, leading to discontinuous price changes, deleveraging, and portfolio-flow reversals. Moreover, the market is subject to contagion-an adverse shock to investors in some locations affects prices everywhere. (JEL D83, G11, G12, G32, G35)
Robust Financial Bubbles

Francesca Biagini,Jacopo Mancin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1602.05471

2016-02-18

Abstract:We study the concept of financial bubble in a market model endowed with a set of probability measures, typically mutually singular to each other. In this setting we introduce the notions of robust bubble and robust fundamental value in a consistent way with the existing literature in the case a unique prior exists. The notion of no dominance is also investigated under the uncertainty framework. Finally, we provide concrete examples illustrating our results.

Mathematical Finance
Simulations for models with heterogeneous agents, incomplete markets, real assets and aggregate uncertainty

Damian Pierri

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11403-024-00415-1

2024-06-24

Journal of Economic Interaction and Coordination

Abstract:This paper presents conditions to guarantee the convergence of simulations to a stochastic steady state, characterized by an invariant probability distribution, in an endowment economy with a finite number of heterogeneous agents, 1 period real assets offered in zero net supply, aggregate uncertainty, incomplete markets and uncountable shocks. The results are robust to the presence of multiple discontinuous equilibria and are numerically implementable. We work on a Markov environment with an enlarged state space to characterize ergodic equilibria and differentiate them with respect to time-independent and stationary ones. We show, by imposing a mild restriction on the discontinuity set, that every measurable time-independent selection approximates the stochastic steady state of the model. The results in this paper are constructive and based on assumptions imposed on the primitives of the model. Thus, they can help to design calibration and estimation methods for heterogeneous agent models based on unconditional moments.

economics
Robust Market Convergence: From Discrete to Continuous Time

David Criens

2024-10-16

Abstract:Continuous time financial market models are often motivated as scaling limits of discrete time models. The objective of this paper is to establish such a connection for a robust framework. More specifically, we consider discrete time models that are parameterized by Markovian transition kernels, and a continuous time framework with drift and volatility uncertainty, again parameterized in a Markovian way. Our main result is a limit theory that establishes convergence of the uncertainty sets in the Hausdorff metric topology and weak convergence of the associated worst-case expectations. Furthermore, we discuss a structure preservation property of certain approximations. Namely, we establish the convergence of discrete to continuous time robust superhedging prices for some complete robust market models. As illustration of our main results, we use the idea of Kushner's Markov chain approximation method and provide a recursive algorithm for the computation of continuous time robust superhedging prices.

Probability,Optimization and Control
Compact Securities Markets for Pareto Optimal Reallocation of Risk

David M. Pennock,Michael P. Wellman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1301.3886

2013-01-16

Computer Science and Game Theory

Abstract:The emph{securities market} is the fundamental theoretical framework in economics and finance for resource allocation under uncertainty. Securities serve both to reallocate risk and to disseminate probabilistic information. emph{Complete} securities markets - which contain one security for every possible state of nature - support Pareto optimal allocations of risk. Complete markets suffer from the same exponential dependence on the number of underlying events as do joint probability distributions. We examine whether markets can be structured and "compacted" in the same manner as Bayesian network representations of joint distributions. We show that, if all agents' risk-neutral independencies agree with the independencies encoded in the market structure, then the market is emph{operationally complete}: risk is still Pareto optimally allocated, yet the number of securities can be exponentially smaller. For collections of agents of a certain type, agreement on Markov independencies is sufficient to admit compact and operationally complete markets.
Robust no-free lunch with vanishing risk, a continuum of assets and proportional transaction costs

Bruno Bouchard,Emmanuel Lepinette,Erik Taflin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1302.0361

2013-02-02

Abstract:We propose a continuous time model for financial markets with proportional transactions costs and a continuum of risky assets. This is motivated by bond markets in which the continuum of assets corresponds to the continuum of possible maturities. Our framework is well adapted to the study of no-arbitrage properties and related hedging problems. In particular, we extend the Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing of Guasoni, Rásonyi and Lépinette (2012) which concentrates on the one dimensional case. Namely, we prove that the Robust No Free Lunch with Vanishing Risk assumption is equivalent to the existence of a Strictly Consistent Price System. Interestingly, the presence of transaction costs allows a natural definition of trading strategies and avoids all the technical and un-natural restrictions due to stochastic integration that appear in bond models without friction. We restrict to the case where exchange rates are continuous in time and leave the general càdlàg case for further studies.

Pricing of Securities,Probability
Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing under Transaction costs and Model uncertainty

Erhan Bayraktar,Yuchong Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1309.1420

2015-08-31

Abstract:We prove the Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing for a discrete time financial market where trading is subject to proportional transaction cost and the asset price dynamic is modeled by a family of probability measures, possibly non-dominated. Using a backward-forward scheme, we show that when the market consists of a money market account and a single stock, no-arbitrage in a quasi-sure sense is equivalent to the existence of a suitable family of consistent price systems. We also show that when the market consists of multiple dynamically traded assets and satisfies \emph{efficient friction}, strict no-arbitrage in a quasi-sure sense is equivalent to the existence of a suitable family of strictly consistent price systems.

Probability,Pricing of Securities
Balance, growth and diversity of financial markets

Constantinos Kardaras

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0803.1858

2008-03-13

Abstract:A financial market comprising of a certain number of distinct companies is considered, and the following statement is proved: either a specific agent will surely beat the whole market unconditionally in the long run, or (and this "or" is not exclusive) all the capital of the market will accumulate in one company. Thus, absence of any "free unbounded lunches relative to the total capital" opportunities lead to the most dramatic failure of diversity in the market: one company takes over all other until the end of time. In order to prove this, we introduce the notion of perfectly balanced markets, which is an equilibrium state in which the relative capitalization of each company is a martingale under the physical probability. Then, the weaker notion of balanced markets is discussed where the martingale property of the relative capitalizations holds only approximately, we show how these concepts relate to growth-optimality and efficiency of the market, as well as how we can infer a shadow interest rate that is implied in the economy in the absence of a bank.

General Finance,Probability
Partial Equilibria with Convex Capital Requirements: Existence, Uniqueness and Stability

Michail Anthropelos,Gordan Zitkovic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0901.3318

2009-01-22

Abstract:In an incomplete semimartingale model of a financial market, we consider several risk-averse financial agents who negotiate the price of a bundle of contingent claims. Assuming that the agents' risk preferences are modelled by convex capital requirements, we define and analyze their demand functions and propose a notion of a partial equilibrium price. In addition to sufficient conditions for the existence and uniqueness, we also show that the equilibrium prices are stable with respect to misspecifications of agents' risk preferences.

Risk Management
Financial market with no riskless (safe) asset

Svetlozar Rachev,Frank Fabozzi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1612.02112

2016-12-07

Abstract:We study markets with no riskless (safe) asset. We derive the corresponding Black-Scholes-Merton option pricing equations for markets where there are only risky assets which have the following price dynamics: (i) continuous diffusions; (ii) jump-diffusions; (iii) diffusions with stochastic volatilities, and; (iv) geometric fractional Brownian and Rosenblatt motions. No arbitrage and market completeness conditions are derived in all four cases.

Mathematical Finance
On statistical indistinguishability of the complete and incomplete markets

Nikolai Dokuchaev

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1209.4695

2012-09-21

Pricing of Securities

Abstract:The possibility of statistical evaluation of the market completeness and incompleteness is investigated for continuous time diffusion stock market models. It is known that the market completeness is not a robust property: small random deviations of the coefficients convert a complete market model into a incomplete one. The paper shows that market incompleteness is also non-robust: small deviations can convert an incomplete model into a complete one. More precisely, it is shown that, for any incomplete market from a wide class of models, there exists a complete market model with arbitrarily close paths of the stock prices and the market parameters. This leads to a counterintuitive conclusion that the incomplete markets are indistinguishable from the complete markets in the terms of the market statistics.
Modelling Financial Markets by Self-Organized Criticality

A. E. Biondo,A. Pluchino,A. Rapisarda

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.92.042814

2015-10-08

Abstract:We present a financial market model, characterized by self-organized criticality, that is able to generate endogenously a realistic price dynamics and to reproduce well-known stylized facts. We consider a community of heterogeneous traders, composed by chartists and fundamentalists, and focus on the role of informative pressure on market participants, showing how the spreading of information, based on a realistic imitative behavior, drives contagion and causes market fragility. In this model imitation is not intended as a change in the agent's group of origin, but is referred only to the price formation process. We introduce in the community also a variable number of random traders in order to study their possible beneficial role in stabilizing the market, as found in other studies. Finally we also suggest some counterintuitive policy strategies able to dampen fluctuations by means of a partial reduction of information.

Statistical Finance,Physics and Society
Market structure and competitive equilibrium in dynamic economic models

Randall D Wright

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-0531(87)90013-5

IF: 1.79

1987-02-01

Journal of Economic Theory

Abstract:Recently theorists have analyzed economies which potentially contain both finite and infinite horizon overlapping generations, using “Arrow-Debreu” (complete) markets. Typically, applied models assume recursive spot and contingent securities markets, implying a different equilibrium concept. Indeed, if infinite horizon agents are present recursive equilibria cannot exist without some side conditions on debt. With the right side conditions, we show that every recursive market equilibrium allocation is a complete market equilibrium allocation and vice versa. This bridges a gap between theory and applications, and extends existing equivalence results on market structure.

economics
Levels of complexity in financial markets

Giovanni Bonanno,Fabrizio Lillo,Rosario N. Mantegna

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371%2801%2900279-5

2001-04-19

Abstract:We consider different levels of complexity which are observed in the empirical investigation of financial time series. We discuss recent empirical and theoretical work showing that statistical properties of financial time series are rather complex under several ways. Specifically, they are complex with respect to their (i) temporal and (ii) ensemble properties. Moreover, the ensemble return properties show a behavior which is specific to the nature of the trading day reflecting if it is a normal or an extreme trading day.

Statistical Mechanics,Statistical Finance
Cost-efficiency in Incomplete Markets

Carole Bernard,Stephan Sturm

2024-07-05

Abstract:This paper studies the topic of cost-efficiency in incomplete markets. A payoff is called cost-efficient if it achieves a given probability distribution at some given investment horizon with a minimum initial budget. Extensive literature exists for the case of a complete financial market. We show how the problem can be extended to incomplete markets and how the main results from the theory of complete markets still hold in adapted form. In particular, we find that in incomplete markets, the optimal portfolio choice for non-decreasing preferences that are diversification-loving (a notion introduced in this paper) must be "perfectly" cost-efficient. This notion of perfect cost-efficiency is shown to be equivalent to the fact that the payoff can be rationalized, i.e., it is the solution to an expected utility problem.

Portfolio Management,Probability,Mathematical Finance
Quasi-sure essential supremum and applications to finance

Laurence Carassus

2024-03-19

Abstract:When uncertainty is modelled by a set of non-dominated and non-compact probability measures, a notion of essential supremum for a family of real-valued functions is developed in terms of upper semi-analytic functions. We show how the properties postulated on the initial functions carry over to their quasi-sure essential supremum. We propose various applications to financial problems with frictions. We analyse super-replication and prove a bi-dual characterization of the super-hedging cost. We also study a weak no-arbitrage condition called Absence of Instantaneous Profit (AIP) under which prices are finite. This requires new results on the aggregation of quasi-sure statements.

Mathematical Finance

Complete and competitive financial markets in a complex world

Partial Equilibrium and Market Completion

Asset Pricing in an Imperfect World

Existence of financial equilibria in continuous time with potentially complete markets

Financial equilibria in the semimartingale setting: complete markets and markets with withdrawal constraints

Financial Entanglement: A Theory of Incomplete Integration, Leverage, Crashes, and Contagion

Robust Financial Bubbles

Simulations for models with heterogeneous agents, incomplete markets, real assets and aggregate uncertainty

Robust Market Convergence: From Discrete to Continuous Time

Compact Securities Markets for Pareto Optimal Reallocation of Risk

Robust no-free lunch with vanishing risk, a continuum of assets and proportional transaction costs

Fundamental Theorem of Asset Pricing under Transaction costs and Model uncertainty

Balance, growth and diversity of financial markets

Partial Equilibria with Convex Capital Requirements: Existence, Uniqueness and Stability

Financial market with no riskless (safe) asset

On statistical indistinguishability of the complete and incomplete markets

Modelling Financial Markets by Self-Organized Criticality

Market structure and competitive equilibrium in dynamic economic models

Levels of complexity in financial markets

Cost-efficiency in Incomplete Markets

Quasi-sure essential supremum and applications to finance