Healthcare Workers: Heroes or Victims? Context of the Western World and Proposals to Prevent Violence

Gianpietro Volonnino,Federica Spadazzi,Lina De Paola,Mauro Arcangeli,Natascha Pascale,Paola Frati,Raffaele La Russa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/healthcare12070708

2024-03-24

Health Care

Abstract:Episodes of direct violence against healthcare workers and social workers represent a worrying and widespread phenomenon in Western countries. These violent attacks, whether verbal or physical, occur in various work environments, targeting professionals working in private facilities, medical practices, or those employed within the National Health System facilities. We conducted a search using a single search engine (PubMed) using the terms "violence against healthcare workers AND Western" for the period 2003–2023, identifying 45 results to which we added to the literature through hand searching. Our review thus analyzed the sector literature to highlight the phenomenon of violence against healthcare workers, particularly in Western countries. We began with an analysis of the problem and then focused on the true purpose of the study, which is to propose new solutions to protect healthcare workers in all work settings. Consequently, we aim to improve both the working environment for healthcare professionals and to enhance the overall healthcare and public health outcomes.

health care sciences & services,health policy & services

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What Problem Does the Paper Attempt to Solve?

This paper explores the issue of violence against healthcare workers in Western countries and proposes new solutions to ensure the safety of healthcare workers in various work environments. Specifically:

1. **Phenomenon Analysis**:
- The paper first analyzes the phenomenon of direct violence (including physical and verbal violence) against healthcare workers, particularly prevalent in Western countries.
- Data shows that such incidents mainly occur in hospital emergency departments, targeting emergency medical workers. The World Health Organization estimates that 8% to 38% of healthcare workers experience physical violence during their careers, with even more facing threats or verbal attacks.

2. **Research Objectives**:
- The main objective of the research is to propose new solutions to protect healthcare workers in all work environments.
- These proposals aim not only to improve the working conditions of medical professionals but also to enhance overall healthcare services and public health outcomes.

3. **Literature Review Methodology**:
- Researchers used the PubMed search engine to retrieve literature on "violence against healthcare workers" and "Western" from 2003 to 2023, finding a total of 45 relevant articles.
- After excluding irrelevant literature, 27 articles were included for detailed analysis.

4. **Summary of Results**:
- The phenomenon of direct violence against healthcare workers is widespread, especially in nursing homes and hospitals, particularly in emergency departments.
- Most violent incidents are perpetrated by patients and their families, with verbal violence being the most common.
- The reporting rate is lower than the actual occurrence rate due to reasons such as fear of retaliation, reluctance to appear weak, and repeated incidents being reported only once.

5. **Global Perspective**:
- The issue of violence against healthcare workers is a global problem, particularly severe in Asian countries.
- Data from the United States shows that from 2011 to 2013, there were over 23,540 workplace assault incidents annually, with more than 70% occurring in healthcare and social service settings.
- Data from Italy also indicates that from 2019 to 2021, there were over 4,800 violent incidents, most of which were perpetrated by patients and their families.

6. **Legislative Measures**:
- To address this issue, many countries and regions have implemented legislative measures to protect healthcare workers, such as establishing national observatories and increasing penalties.
- Italy has passed several laws, such as Decree No. 113 of 2020, aimed at enhancing the safety of healthcare workers and establishing a dedicated national observatory.

Overall, this paper aims to reveal the violence faced by healthcare workers and propose effective solutions to improve their working conditions and enhance the overall level of healthcare services.