Evaluation of a single-layer urban energy balance model using measured energy fluxes by scaled outdoor experiments in humid subtropical climate

Jian Hang,Liyue Zeng,Xianxiang Li,Dongyang Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2024.111364
IF: 7.093
2024-02-28
Building and Environment
Abstract:Urban energy balance models can simulate the localized climate and fluxes in urban areas. They are often evaluated using real urban site observations. However, uncertainties in anthropogenic emission, geometry and materials can hinder interpretation. These uncertainties can be eliminated by scaled outdoor models. We assess the performance of a single-layer urban canopy model (SLUCM) offline in predicting surface energy balance (SEB) fluxes within a street canyon-like urban configuration using field measurements from a scaled outdoor setup in Guangzhou, China. We utilize observations of SEB fluxes and surface temperature from a homogenous scaled urban site characterized by street canyons. The scaled observations in June–December 2020 in a dense urban environment with a height-to-width ratio ( H/W ) of 2 are employed to assess seasonal variations in model performance. Additionally, the December data from two distinct urban scenarios ( H/W = 2(2020) and 0.5(2019)) are utilized to compare model performance in deep and shallow street canyon settings. Results show that Q S ( R 2 = ∼0.47, RMSE = ∼46.0) is the most challenging to predict, followed by Q H ( R 2 = ∼0.92, RMSE = ∼65.5), Q* ( R 2 = ∼0.99, RMSE = ∼39.5), L ↑( R 2 = ∼0.95, RMSE = ∼33.7), and K ↑( R 2 = ∼0.99, RMSE = ∼6.2). SLUCM faces difficulties simulating L↑ particularly during nighttime and cloudy conditions. It also tends to underestimate daytime net radiation ( Q *), especially during hot, humid months. Moreover, H/W ratio slightly affects SLUCM's performance in simulating SEB fluxes under dry cool conditions denser urban settings ( H/W = 2) show better model performance in K↑, Q H , and Q S but worse performance in L↑ and Q* .
engineering, environmental,construction & building technology, civil
What problem does this paper attempt to address?