A maximum bathymetric depth model to simulate satellite photon-counting lidar performance

Wenhao Zhang,Nan Xu,Yue Ma,Bisheng Yang,Zhiyu Zhang,Xiao Hua Wang,Song Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isprsjprs.2021.02.013
IF: 12.7
2021-04-01
ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing
Abstract:<p>With the development of photon-counting sensors, spaceborne photon-counting lidars have shown many advantages in mapping underwater topography. Although a space based lidar is normally a profiling system, the depth penetration and the vertical accuracy achieved with a bathymetric lidar is superior to imagery (that only provides relative depths). Therefore, many satellite derived bathymetry products use both active/passive spaceborne data to achieve spatial coverage as well as absolute depth measurements. Compared with shipborne and airborne bathymetric systems, satellite derived bathymetry data can have a global coverage, especially covering some remote areas where airborne/shipborne systems are hard or very expensive to reach. In this paper, a theoretical model is proposed to quantitatively analyze the maximum bathymetric depth of a satellite photon-counting lidar, which considers the system parameters, environmental effects, and the constraint of the SNR (signal to noise ratio). System parameters of ICESat-2 (Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite-2) as well as the MODIS (Moderate-resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer) and NCEP (National Centers for Environmental Prediction) datasets are used to provide systematic and environmental inputs to the model, and the ICESat-2 actual bathymetric data are used to verify the maximum depth estimated by the proposed model. In six different sites with different water qualities, solar angles and wind speeds, the theoretical maximum bathymetric depths agree well with the actually achieved ICESat-2 lidar depths, in terms of MAE (mean absolute error) of 0.50 m and the RMSE (root mean square error) of 0.60 m. The errors in all study areas are within 14% of the corresponding maximum depths. Additionally, the non-linear response of a photon-counting lidar, independent parameter impacts on the theoretical model, and the errors in the experimental process were quantitatively analyzed. In the future, this theoretical model can be used to evaluate the maximum bathymetric depth for a bathymetry investigation when applying system parameters and environmental parameters. In addition, it can be used to optimize the hardware parameters of a photon-counting lidar in its early design process.</p>
imaging science & photographic technology,remote sensing,geography, physical,geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to quantitatively analyze the maximum water - depth measurement capacity of satellite photon - counting lidar by establishing a theoretical model. Specifically, this model takes into account system parameters, environmental effects, and the constraints of signal - to - noise ratio (SNR), aiming to evaluate the maximum water depth that satellite photon - counting lidar can reach under different water quality, solar angle, and wind speed conditions. ### Background and Problem Description With the development of photon - counting sensors, space photon - counting lidar has shown many advantages in mapping underwater topography. Although space - based lidar is usually a profiling system, its penetration depth and vertical accuracy far exceed those of images (which can only provide relative depth). Therefore, many satellite - based water - depth products combine active and passive space data to achieve spatial coverage and absolute depth measurement. Compared with ship - borne and airborne water - depth systems, satellite - based water - depth data can achieve global coverage, especially in some remote areas that are difficult to reach or costly. ### Research Objectives This paper proposes a theoretical model for quantitatively analyzing the maximum water depth of satellite photon - counting lidar. This model takes into account system parameters, environmental impacts, and the constraints of signal - to - noise ratio (SNR). The research uses the system parameters of ICESat - 2 (Ice, Cloud, and land Elevation Satellite - 2), and the data sets of MODIS (Moderate - Resolution Imaging Spectrometer) and NCEP (National Centers for Environmental Prediction) as system and environmental inputs, and uses the actual water - depth data of ICESat - 2 to verify the maximum water depth estimated by the proposed model. ### Main Contributions 1. **Establishment of a Theoretical Model**: Proposed a theoretical model that takes into account system parameters, environmental effects, and signal - to - noise ratio constraints for quantitatively analyzing the maximum water depth of satellite photon - counting lidar. 2. **Practical Verification**: Verification was carried out at six locations with different water quality, solar angles, and wind speeds. The average absolute error (MAE) between the theoretical maximum water depth and the actual ICESat - 2 lidar water depth was 0.50 meters, and the root - mean - square error (RMSE) was 0.60 meters. The error was within 14% of the maximum depth in all research areas. 3. **Non - linear Response Analysis**: Quantitative analysis was carried out on the non - linear response of photon - counting lidar, the influence of independent parameters on the theoretical model, and the errors in the experimental process. ### Future Applications This theoretical model can be used to evaluate the maximum water depth when applying system parameters and environmental parameters for water - depth surveys. In addition, it can also optimize hardware parameters in the early design process of photon - counting lidar. ### Conclusions By establishing and verifying this theoretical model, the research provides a scientific basis for the maximum water - depth measurement capacity of satellite photon - counting lidar, which helps to improve the accuracy and reliability of water - depth measurement.