(312) Manhandling: Post-IPP Mechanical Therapy – A Scoping Review

R Calopedos,K Khalafalla,R Pham,R Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/jsxmed/qdae001.297
2024-02-07
The Journal of Sexual Medicine
Abstract:Introduction While inflatable penile prosthesis (IPP) allows reliable axial rigidity, common complaints are perceived shorter penis and reduced glans engorgement. Pre-operative factors, such as vasculogenic erectile dysfunction (ED) or corporoglandular morphology, provide a convenient explanation. However, post-operative factors are more recently being interrogated. Post-IPP mechanical therapy protocols, like vacuum erection devices (VED), are being instituted to ameliorate these complaints. The physiological rationale is to improve perfusion of the residual erectile tissues and limit cavernous fibrosis or pseudo-capsule formation. This has been hypothetically explained by upregulating release of endothelial nitrous oxide synthase, decreasing hypoxia inducible factor  and tissue growth factor □1. Post-IPP maximal inflation protocols may similarly result in a more capacious and compliant tunica albuginea and capsule. Objective To assess the utility of post-IPP mechanical therapy in addressing common post-operative complaints and enhance prosthetic erection. Methods Intervention: Post-op mechanical therapy Population: Men with IPP for ED, with/without Peyronie's disease (PD) Inclusion Criteria: Articles published in English with full-text available Search Strategy: Literature search was performed in June 2023 using Medline, PubMed, Embase and Scopus. PubMed search included both "Mesh" protocols and "free text" to capture the correct study population. Articles relating to the intervention were identified with free text search searches ("VED," "vacuum erection device," "vacuum constriction device," "vacuum," "penis pump," "mechanical therapy," or "rehabilitation"). Review Type & Analysis: While a systematic model was initially adopted, a scoping model was ultimately chosen given the limited available literature and variable outcome measures. In this way, we sought to identify knowledge gaps and the scope of current literature to guide further studies in this field. Higher-powered analyses were not possible due to inter-study outcome measure variability. Results Initial search strategy retrieved 81 non-duplicate studies with 30 selected for initial screening after search limitations. Ultimately, 5 satisfied inclusion criteria after full-text review and were divided into 3 categories relating to the post-IPP protocol employed: Early activation (1), Maximal inflation (2,3) and VED (4,5) (Table 1). A common theme encountered was that mechanical therapy improved post-IPP penile length and girth, compared to immediate post-operative measurements. Only one study used a control group who had their device activated for the first time after 4 weeks. The intervention employed in this study was device activation immediately after surgery, left 80% inflated and deflated at 2-3 weeks, then full erection at night for 3-4 further weeks. Compared to the control, at maximum inflation, penile length mean was 3.28 cm longer and circumference was 1 cm greater. In each of these studies, the differences reported were statistically significant. This was also associated with an increased number of pumps required to achieve full inflation over time, irrespective of mechanical protocol used. Articles that reported IIEF-5 and EDITS scores also demonstrated a statistically significant improvement over time with post-op intervention. Conclusions Within limits of the included studies, post-implantation mechanical therapy appears to be useful in improving penile dimensions and patient satisfaction over time. The correlation with increasing number of pumps implies that compliance of the tunica albuginea and residual cavernous tissue may play a role in the pathogenesis of shorter penis post-IPP. Further high-powered studies in this area are warranted. Disclosure No.
urology & nephrology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are the shortened penile length and reduced glans engorgement that patients commonly complain about after the implantation of an Inflatable Penile Prosthesis (IPP). These problems may be caused by preoperative factors such as vascular Erectile Dysfunction (ED) or abnormal glans morphology, but recent studies have begun to focus on postoperative factors. Specifically, the paper explores whether postoperative mechanical therapies (such as Vacuum Erection Devices, VED) can improve these postoperative problems and enhance the effect of prosthesis erection. ### Background and Purpose of the Paper **Background**: - IPP is an effective method for treating erectile dysfunction and can provide reliable axial rigidity. - However, patients often complain of a shorter penis and insufficient glans engorgement after the operation. - Preoperative factors such as vascular erectile dysfunction or abnormal glans morphology can explain some of the problems, but postoperative factors are also gradually receiving attention. - Postoperative mechanical therapies (such as VED) are used to improve the perfusion of the remaining erectile tissue and limit cavernous fibrosis or pseudo - capsule formation. **Physiological Mechanisms**: - By up - regulating the release of endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), reducing the expression of hypoxia - inducible factor (HIF) and tissue growth factor β1. - The maximum inflation protocol may make the tunica albuginea and the capsule more voluminous and compliant. **Purpose**: - To evaluate the effectiveness of postoperative mechanical therapies in solving common postoperative problems and enhancing prosthesis erection. ### Methods - **Interventions**: Postoperative mechanical therapies - **Study Subjects**: Men with erectile dysfunction who have received IPP treatment, including patients with or without Peyronie’s Disease (PD) - **Inclusion Criteria**: Articles published in English and with the full text available - **Search Strategy**: A literature search was conducted using Medline, PubMed, Embase, and Scopus in June 2023. The PubMed search included the “Mesh” protocol and “free text” to capture the correct study population. - **Article Identification**: Relevant articles were identified using free - text search keywords (such as “VED”, “Vacuum Erection Device”, “Vacuum Constriction Device”, “Vacuum Pump”, “Mechanical Therapy” or “Rehabilitation”). - **Review Type and Analysis**: Initially, a systematic review model was adopted, but due to limited literature and inconsistent outcome measurement indicators, a scoping review model was finally selected, aiming to identify knowledge gaps and the scope of current literature to guide further research. ### Results - The initial search strategy retrieved 81 non - duplicate studies. After screening, 30 entered the preliminary screening, and finally 5 met the inclusion criteria. - These studies were divided into three categories: early activation (1 study), maximum inflation (2 studies), and VED (2 studies). - A common theme was that mechanical therapies improved the postoperative penile length and girth compared to the immediate postoperative measurements. - One study used a control group. The control group activated the device for the first time 4 weeks after the operation. The intervention group activated the device immediately after the operation, maintained an 80% inflated state for 2 - 3 weeks, and then had a full erection at night for 3 - 4 weeks. Compared with the control group, the intervention group had an average penile length that was 3.28 cm longer and a girth that was 1 cm larger in the maximum inflation state. - All the differences reported in all studies were statistically significant. - Over time, regardless of which mechanical therapy was used, the number of pumps required to reach full inflation increased. - Articles reporting IIEF - 5 and EDITS scores also showed that postoperative interventions significantly improved these scores over time. ### Conclusions Within the scope of the included studies, postoperative mechanical therapies seem to help improve penile size and patient satisfaction. As the number of inflations increases, the compliance of the tunica albuginea and the residual cavernous tissue may play a role in the pathological mechanism of postoperative penile shortening. More high - power studies are needed in the future to further verify this area.