Depression and Personality Traits Across Adolescence—Within-Person Analyses of a Birth Cohort

Ida Sund Morken,Lars Wichstrøm,Silje Steinsbekk,Kristine Rensvik Viddal,Morken, Ida Sund
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10802-024-01188-8
2024-03-29
Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology
Abstract:Depressive symptoms and personality traits covary in adolescents, but our understanding of the nature of this relation is limited. Whereas a predisposition explanation posits that specific personality traits increase the vulnerability for developing depression, a scar explanation proposes that depression may alter premorbid personality. Attempts to test these explanatory models have relied on analyses that conflate within-person changes and between-person differences, which limits the implications that can be drawn. Moreover, research on the early adolescent years is lacking. The present study therefore examined within-person associations between depressive symptoms and Big Five personality traits across ages 10 to 16. Children ( n = 817; 49.9% boys) and parents from two birth cohorts in Trondheim, Norway, were assessed biennially with clinical interviews capturing symptoms of major depressive disorder and dysthymia, and self-reported Big Five personality traits. Analyses were conducted using a random intercept cross-lagged panel model, which accounts for all unmeasured time-invariant confounding effects. Increased Neuroticism predicted an increased number of depressive symptoms—and increased depressive symptoms predicted increased Neuroticism—across ages 10 to 14. Moreover, increased depressive symptoms forecast reduced Extraversion across ages 10 to 16, and reduced Conscientiousness from ages 12 to 14. Increases in Neuroticism may contribute to the development of depressive symptoms—in line with the predisposition model. As regards the scar model, depression may have an even wider impact on personality traits: increasing Neuroticism and reducing Extraversion and Conscientiousness. These effects may already be present in the earliest adolescent years.
psychology, clinical, developmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between depressive symptoms in adolescence and the Big Five personality traits, especially in the early adolescence stage (ages 10 to 16). The research aims to test two explanatory models: 1. **Predisposition Model**: Do specific personality traits increase the risk of adolescents developing depression? For example, does high Neuroticism predict more depressive symptoms? 2. **Scar Model**: Does depression affect the pre - morbid personality traits of adolescents? For example, do depressive symptoms increase the level of Neuroticism and reduce Extraversion and Conscientiousness? To test these models more accurately, the research adopts the Random Intercept Cross - Lagged Panel Model (RI - CLPM). This method can distinguish between group differences and within - individual changes, thus avoiding the problem of ecological fallacy in traditional methods. In addition, the research also pays special attention to the data of the age group from 10 to 16 years old, filling the gap in the existing research in the early adolescence stage. ### Research Background - **Depression**: It usually appears in adolescence and becomes one of the most common mental disorders. Even sub - clinical levels of depressive symptoms can have a negative impact on family, school and peer relationships. - **Personality Traits**: Measured using the Five - Factor Model (FFM), including Neuroticism, Extraversion, Conscientiousness, Agreeableness and Openness. These traits can already be identified in children aged 10. - **Theoretical Models**: - **Predisposition Model**: Personality traits may increase the risk of developing depression. - **Scar Model**: Depression may lead to permanent changes in personality traits. - Other models also include the pathoplasty/exacerbation model, the spectrum/continuity model and the common - factor model. ### Research Objectives - **Methodological Innovation**: Adopt the RI - CLPM method to separate between - group and within - individual information and avoid confounding variables in traditional methods. - **Age Range Expansion**: Include adolescents aged 10 to 16, especially focus on the data before the age of 12, because this age group is a period when the incidence of depression increases significantly. - **Data Sources**: Use clinical interviews to assess depressive symptoms and self - assessment questionnaires to assess personality traits to reduce common method bias. Through these methods, the research aims to more accurately understand the dynamic relationship between depressive symptoms and personality traits in adolescence and provide a scientific basis for the prevention and treatment of adolescent depression.