Head Impact Exposure in Hawaiian High School Football: Influence of Adherence Rates on a Helmetless Tackling and Blocking Training Intervention
Erik E Swartz,Jay L Myers,Jong Soo Lee,Steven P Broglio,Troy Furutani,Ross Oshiro,Gerard A Gioia,Darian Brothers,Kiera Glodowski,Ivet Lloansi,Lauren Meyer,Nathan Murata
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4085/1062-6050-0014.24
2024-04-18
Journal of Athletic Training
Abstract:Abstract Context High school football remains a popular, physically demanding sport despite the known risks for acute brain and neck injury. Impacts to the head also raise concerns about their cumulative effects and long-term health consequences. Objective To examine the effectiveness of a helmetless tackling training program to reduce head impact exposure in football participants. Design A three-year, quasi-experimental, prospective cohort (clinicaltrials.gov #NCTXXX) study. Setting Honolulu (XXX, XXX) area public and private secondary schools with varsity and junior varsity football. Patients or Other Participants Football participants (n=496) ages 14 to 18 years old. Intervention(s) Participants wore new football helmets furnished with head impact sensor technology. Teams employed a season-long helmetless tackling and blocking intervention in Years 2 and 3 consisting of a 3-phase, systematic progression of 10 instructional drills. Main Outcome Measure(s) Head impact frequency per athlete exposure (ImpAE), location, and impact magnitude per participant intervention adherence levels (60% and 80%). Results An overall regression analysis revealed a significant negative association between ImpAE and adherence (p=0.003, beta=-1.21, SE=0.41). In year 3, a longitudinal data analysis of weekly ImpAE data resulted in an overall difference between the adherent and non-adherent groups (p=0.040 at 80%; p=0.004 at 60%), mainly due to decreases in top and side impacts. Mean cumulative impact burden for the adherent group (n=131: 2,105.84g ± 219.76,) was significantly (p=0.020) less than the non-adherent group (n=90: 3,158.25g ± 434.80) at the 60% adherence level. Conclusions Participants adhering to the intervention on at least a 60% level experienced a 34% to 37% significant reduction in the number of head impacts (per exposure) through the season. These results provide additional evidence that a helmetless tackling and blocking training intervention (utilizing the HuTT® program) reduces head impact exposure in high school football players. Adherence to an intervention is crucial for achieving intended outcomes.
sport sciences