Abstract:This paper provides a summary survey of the policy approaches to artificial intelligence-based technologies in China, the European Union, and the United States. China has the most aggressive approach, launching major initiatives since 2015 such as ‘Made in China 2025’, the Internet Plus Plan, the New Generation Artificial Intelligence Development Plan, and the Artificial Intelligence Standardization White Paper. In 2018, the EU finalized both the European AI Strategy and ‘Made in Europe’ or the Coordinated Plan on the Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence. Despite a traditional reticence to adopt national strategies and perhaps pushed by growing concerns about China, the US Government announced the American AI Initiative and a National AI R&D Strategic Plan in 2019. The AI approaches in these three economies reflect their relative strengths—state control in China, citizen voice in Europe, and business practices in America. Unencumbered by privacy concerns, China’s strategy is geared to exploit the abundance of domestic data and to develop AI talent through central schemes and massive injections of money. The European Union’s regulations and spending priorities are guided by the objective of building citizen trust in AI-based technologies by safeguarding privacy and ameliorating disruptions in national labor markets. The mainstay of the US approach is to strengthen the linkages between business and AI-related research, and find ways to fund basic R&D. Despite efforts to indigenize AI innovations, all three economies face challenges. China’s AI strategy continues to rely disproportionately on just three tech giants: Baidu, Tencent and Alibaba, which have investments in more than a 100 AI-involved companies. Europe’s AI resources are unbalanced geographically—a quarter of Europe’s AI talent is in the UK and another quarter in Germany and France—and Brexit poses a serious risk. More than half of the AI talent in the US is foreign born, so immigration policies will inevitably be a central component of a national AI strategy.

A survey of the European Union's artificial intelligence ecosystem

The ghost of AI governance past, present and future: AI governance in the European Union

Foundations for the future: institution building for the purpose of artificial intelligence governance

The European map of artificial intelligence development policies: a comparative analysis

The EU AI Act As Global Artificial Intelligence Regulation

Eu AI sovereignty: for whom, to what end, and to whose benefit?

Artificial Intelligence across Europe: A Study on Awareness, Attitude and Trust

Key Factors Affecting European Reactions to AI in European Full and Flawed Democracies

An EU landmark for AI governance

Policy initiatives for Artificial Intelligence-enabled government: An analysis of national strategies in Europe

Human vs. Artificial intelligence: EU's legal response

AI Regulation in the European Union: Examining Non-State Actor Preferences

The Brussels Effect and Artificial Intelligence: How EU regulation will impact the global AI market

Policy Approaches to Artificial Intelligence Based Technologies in China, European Union and the United States

The EU’s Digital Sovereignty - The role of Artificial Intelligence and Competition Policy

Embedding artificial intelligence in society: looking beyond the EU AI master plan using the culture cycle

Mapping the regulatory landscape for artificial intelligence in health within the European Union

AI Hubs: Europe and CANZUK

The EU AI Act is a good start but falls short

First Analysis of the EU Artifical Intelligence Act: Towards a Global Standard for Trustworthy AI?

The European Union Artificial Intelligence Act: the first look at the project