Evaluating method and potential risks of chlorine-resistant bacteria (CRB): A review

Li-Wei Luo,Yin-Hu Wu,Tong Yu,Yun-Hong Wang,Gen-Qiang Chen,Xin Tong,Yuan Bai,Chuang Xu,Hao-Bin Wang,Nozomu Ikuno,Hong-Ying Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2020.116474
IF: 12.8
2021-01-01
Water Research
Abstract:<p>Chlorine-resistant bacteria (CRB) are commonly defined as bacteria with high resistance to chlorine disinfection or bacteria which can survive or even regrow in the residual chlorine. Chlorine disinfection cannot completely control the risks of CRB, such as risks of pathogenicity, antibiotic resistance and microbial growth. Currently, researchers pay more attention to CRB with pathogenicity or antibiotic resistance. The microbial growth risks of non-pathogenic CRB in water treatment and reclamation systems have been neglected to some extent. In this review, these three kinds of risks are all analyzed, and the last one is also highlighted. In order to study CRB, various methods are used to evaluate chlorine resistance. This review summarizes the evaluating methods for chlorine resistance reported in the literatures, and collects the important information about the typical isolated CRB strains including their genera, sources and levels of chlorine resistance. To our knowledge, few review papers have provided such systematic information about CRB. Among 44 typical CRB strains from 17 genera isolated by researchers, <em>Mycobacterium, Bacillus, Legionella, Pseudomonas</em> and <em>Sphingomonas</em> were the five genera with the highest frequency of occurrence in literatures. They are all pathogenic or opportunistic pathogenic bacteria. In addition, although there are many studies on CRB, information about chlorine resistance level is still limited to specie level or strain level. The difference in chlorine resistance level among different bacterial genera is less well understood. An inconvenient truth is that there is still no widely-accepted method to evaluate chlorine resistance and to identify CRB. Due to the lack of a unified method, it is difficult to compare the results about chlorine resistance level of bacterial strains in different literatures. A recommended evaluating method using logarithmic removal rate as an index and <em>E. coli</em> as a reference strain is proposed in this review based on the summary of the current evaluating methods. This method can provide common range of chlorine resistance of each genus and it is conducive to analyzing the distribution and abundance of CRB in the environment.</p>
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental,water resources
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the following problems: 1. **Define and quantify chlorine - resistant bacteria (CRB)**: - At present, there is a lack of a widely accepted scientific definition and quantification method for chlorine - resistant bacteria (CRB). The paper proposes the need to establish a recommended evaluation method to facilitate the comparison of bacterial chlorine tolerance in different studies. 2. **Standardize the evaluation method**: - The existing methods for evaluating chlorine tolerance are diverse and not unified, making it difficult to directly compare the results between different studies. The paper recommends using the log removal rate as an evaluation index and Escherichia coli (*E. coli*) as a reference strain, thus providing a general evaluation method. 3. **Analyze potential risks**: - The paper comprehensively analyzes the potential risks of chlorine - resistant bacteria in water treatment, distribution, and utilization systems, including but not limited to: - **Human health risks**: Some pathogenic or opportunistic pathogenic bacteria are chlorine - tolerant, and these bacteria may regenerate after disinfection, threatening public health. - **Increase in the abundance of antibiotic - resistance genes (ARG)**: The bacteria remaining after chlorine disinfection may have a higher antibiotic - resistance level, which may lead to the spread of antibiotic - resistance genes. - **Impact of microbial growth on the system**: The over - proliferation of non - pathogenic chlorine - resistant bacteria in water treatment systems will lead to membrane fouling, pipe corrosion, biofilm formation, etc., affecting the efficiency and lifespan of the system. 4. **Characteristics of typical chlorine - resistant bacteria**: - The paper summarizes the known genera, sources, and chlorine - tolerance levels of chlorine - resistant bacteria. It specifically points out some frequently occurring genera, such as *Mycobacterium*, *Bacillus*, *Legionella*, *Pseudomonas*, and *Sphingomonas*. By solving the above problems, the paper hopes to provide a systematic framework for the research of chlorine - resistant bacteria and promote the further development of this field.