Greater than the Sum of Its Parts: Combining Entrepreneurial and Sustainable Competencies in Entrepreneurship Education

Planck,Wilhelm,Kobilke,Sailer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16093725
IF: 3.9
2024-04-30
Sustainability
Abstract:Discussions about sustainability and entrepreneurship are often an "either/or" discourse. Many higher-education institutions offer sustainability education programs with the aim of enabling students to think and act sustainably without concrete tools for change. Similarly, many offerings in entrepreneurship fail to address sustainability issues. This article assumes a qualitative, constructivist, systems thinking approach to theorize and analyze the relationships between entrepreneurship and sustainability competencies and makes three contributions to theory and practice. First, it provides a thematic analysis of two important European competence frameworks—for sustainability (GreenComp) and entrepreneurial competencies (EntreComp)—and delineates their relationships. Second, through a case study of an experiential educational format, it offers three educational tools that integrate sustainability and entrepreneurial competencies. Third, it contributes to the growing field of research that combines sustainability and entrepreneurship education. The results of this paper are relevant for policymakers who want to combine sustainability and entrepreneurship in education, as well as for educators looking for methods to combine both competence frameworks.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper attempts to address the issue of how to integrate sustainability and entrepreneurial competencies in entrepreneurship education. Specifically, the authors argue that current discussions on sustainability and entrepreneurship often present a binary opposition of "either-or." Many sustainability education programs offered by higher education institutions aim to enable students to think and act towards sustainable development but lack specific transformative tools. Similarly, many entrepreneurship education programs fail to adequately address sustainability issues. Therefore, the main research question of the paper is to explore how to combine entrepreneurial and sustainability competencies to cultivate students' comprehensive abilities, enabling them to achieve sustainable development goals in practice. ### Main Contributions 1. **Theoretical Analysis**: Through thematic analysis of two important European competency frameworks—the sustainability competency framework (GreenComp) and the entrepreneurial competency framework (EntreComp)—the relationship between the two is clarified. 2. **Educational Tools**: Through an experiential education case study, three educational tools are provided that can combine sustainability and entrepreneurial competencies. 3. **Contribution to the Research Field**: The paper contributes to the research field of integrating sustainability and entrepreneurship education, particularly by providing methods and tools for policymakers and educators to help them integrate these competencies in education. ### Research Background - **Challenges Faced by Higher Education Institutions**: Higher education institutions face multiple crises, including demographic changes, accelerated digital transformation, and new societal, industrial, and political expectations of higher education. Sustainable transformation is a significant driving force for academic organizations to adapt and question their habits. - **Knowledge-Action Gap**: Despite knowing the necessity of climate change and deep sustainable transformation for over 50 years, actual actions remain insufficiently widespread. A similar knowledge-action gap exists in the field of Education for Sustainable Development (ESD). ### Methodology - **Systems Thinking**: Systems thinking is adopted as the research philosophy, emphasizing the interconnections and compatibility between social phenomena. - **Qualitative Thematic Analysis**: Through qualitative thematic analysis of the EntreComp and GreenComp competency frameworks, the overlaps and complementarities between them are identified. ### Results and Analysis 1. **Overlap of Competency Frameworks**: There is significant overlap between the two competency frameworks, particularly in competencies such as "opportunity recognition," "creativity," "vision," "valuing ideas," and "ethical and sustainable thinking." 2. **GreenComp as Part of EntreComp**: The competencies of GreenComp can be seen as a subset of EntreComp, especially the competency of "ethical and sustainable thinking," which almost covers all four competency areas of GreenComp. 3. **Integrated Framework**: Combining the two frameworks can provide a comprehensive competency framework, enabling students to translate sustainable thinking into practical actions, thereby achieving applied sustainability competencies. ### Practical Implications - **Policymakers**: Provides a method to combine sustainability and entrepreneurship education, helping policymakers design more integrated educational policies. - **Educators**: Provides specific educational tools and methods to help educators integrate these competencies into their daily teaching. Through these contributions, the paper aims to provide higher education institutions with a new perspective and approach to cultivate students' sustainability and entrepreneurial competencies, thereby promoting sustainable development in society.