A Novel Multi-Sensor Fusion Algorithm Based on Uncertainty Analysis

Haobai Xue,Maomao Zhang,Peining Yu,Haifeng Zhang,Guozhu Wu,Yi Li,Xiangyuan Zheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s21082713

IF: 3.9

2021-04-12

Sensors

Abstract:During the research and development of multiphase flowmeters, errors are often used to evaluate the advantages and disadvantages of different devices and algorithms, whilst an in-depth uncertainty analysis is seldom carried out. However, limited information is sometimes revealed from the errors, especially when the test data are scant, and this makes an in-depth comparison of different algorithms impossible. In response to this problem, three combinations of sensing methods are implemented, which are the “capacitance and cross-correlation”, the “cross-correlation and differential pressure” and the “differential pressure and capacitance” respectively. The analytical expressions of the gas/liquid flowrate and the associated standard uncertainty have been derived, and Monte Carlo simulations are carried out to determine the desired probability density function. The results obtained through these two approaches are basically the same. Thereafter, the sources of uncertainty for each combination are traced and their respective variations with flowrates are analyzed. Further, the relationship between errors and uncertainty is studied, which demonstrates that the two uncertainty analysis approaches can be a powerful tool for error prediction. Finally, a novel multi-sensor fusion algorithm based on the uncertainty analysis is proposed. This algorithm can minimize the standard uncertainty over the whole flowrate range and thus reduces the measurement error.

engineering, electrical & electronic,chemistry, analytical,instruments & instrumentation

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

The paper aims to address the issue of insufficient measurement accuracy of multiphase flow meters (MPFMs) in the exploration, extraction, transportation, and processing of oil and gas fields. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **Relationship Between Error and Uncertainty**:
- In the development of multiphase flow meters, error is typically used to evaluate the performance of different devices and algorithms. However, when test data is limited, the information provided by error is minimal and cannot deeply compare different algorithms.

2. **Uncertainty Analysis**:
- Three sensor combination methods are proposed: "Capacitance and Cross-Correlation" (Cap + CC), "Cross-Correlation and Differential Pressure" (CC + DP), and "Differential Pressure and Capacitance" (DP + Cap). Through these combinations, analytical expressions for gas and liquid flow rates and their standard uncertainties are derived, and Monte Carlo simulations are used to determine the probability density functions.

3. **Novel Multi-Sensor Fusion Algorithm**:
- A novel multi-sensor fusion algorithm based on uncertainty analysis is proposed. This algorithm can minimize the standard uncertainty across the entire flow rate range, thereby reducing measurement errors.

Through the above research, the paper attempts to trace the sources of error using uncertainty analysis tools and provide guidance for system improvement. Additionally, the paper explores the relationship between error and uncertainty, demonstrating that uncertainty analysis can be a powerful tool for predicting errors.