Economic, environmental, and emergy analysis of China's green tea production

Qiang Xu,Yi Yang,Kelin Hu,Ji Chen,Sylvestre Njakou Djomo,Xiao Yang,Marie Trydeman Knudsen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.spc.2021.04.019
IF: 8.921
2021-10-01
Sustainable Production and Consumption
Abstract:<p>Tea is one of the most popular beverages worldwide, and the sustainability of tea production is of vital strategic importance to tea farmers and stakeholders in its value chain. China is a global leader in tea consumption, production, and export. Here, we conduct a joint economic, life cycle, and emergy analysis to provide a comprehensive picture of the economic and environmental sustainability of China's local and exported tea (tea for domestic consumption vs for export). Although local tea is much more profitable than exported tea, it is also much more environmentally damaging, with impacts being 2.2–64.0 times higher, mainly because of lower yields. Specifically, the GHG emissions of local tea are about 6 times those of exported tea (49.90 vs 8.28 kg CO<sub>2</sub> eq/kg). A life-cycle-based scenario analysis indicates that the environmental impacts of China's local and exported tea can be substantially reduced (by 28–98%) by improving fertilizer use efficiency, adopting new varieties, and using renewable energy. Overall, our results show the environmental sustainability challenge of China's tea production and highlight the urgent need to take mitigation measures. Our study also provides important information for domestic and international tea beverage companies in their potential sustainable supply chain management of different tea products.</p>
environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the economic, environmental, and emergy sustainability issues of green tea production in China. Specifically, the study aims to: 1. **Quantitative Assessment**: Conduct a quantitative evaluation and comparison of the economic characteristics, environmental impacts, and emergy use of the supply chains for two types of tea, both for domestic consumption and export. 2. **Identify Hotspots**: Determine the main sources of environmental impact within these two tea supply chains. 3. **Analyze Optimization Strategies**: Analyze the potential for reducing environmental impacts through strategies such as improving fertilizer use efficiency, introducing new varieties, and using renewable energy, and explore sustainable production optimization strategies. ### Background - **Importance of Tea**: Tea is one of the most popular beverages worldwide, and its sustainable production is of strategic importance to tea farmers and stakeholders in the value chain. - **China's Position in the Tea Industry**: China is one of the largest tea producers, consumers, and exporters globally, but the environmental sustainability of its tea production has not been fully studied. - **Study Area**: The research focuses on Shengzhou City in Zhejiang Province, a significant green tea production base in China, which is representative. ### Methods - **System Boundary**: The study includes three stages: tea cultivation, primary processing, and refining. - **Data Collection**: Data were collected from over 100 tea gardens and about 80 tea processing factories through questionnaires. - **Life Cycle Assessment (LCA)**: The environmental impacts of the entire life cycle from cultivation to refining were assessed. - **Economic Analysis**: A simple cost-benefit analysis was conducted to evaluate the profitability of the two tea products. - **Emergy Analysis**: The solar energy equivalents of various inputs in the system were assessed to comprehensively evaluate the system's sustainability. ### Main Findings - **Economic Benefits**: Local tea is more profitable than export tea, but the costs are also higher. The total cost of local tea is 24 times that of export tea, the revenue is 40 times, and the profit is 75 times. - **Environmental Impact**: The environmental impact of local tea is much greater than that of export tea, especially in terms of greenhouse gas emissions, with local tea emissions being 6 times higher. - **Optimization Strategies**: By improving fertilizer use efficiency, introducing new varieties, and using renewable energy, environmental impacts can be significantly reduced, with a maximum reduction of 98%. ### Conclusion - **Environmental Challenges**: The study reveals the environmental sustainability challenges faced by China's tea production and emphasizes the urgency of taking mitigation measures. - **Management Recommendations**: Provides potential sustainable supply chain management information for domestic and international tea companies, helping to improve the environmental and economic benefits of tea production.