Abstract:Oceanic basalts show variation in their iron and magnesium isotope compositions. One hypothesis for the origin of this is source variation: radiogenic isotope and trace element abundance studies have long argued that the Earth's upper mantle is geochemically heterogeneous and that subducted crust is a major contributor to this diversity. In contrast, a recent hypothesis posits that stable isotopes record disequilibrium during melt transport and so provide novel insight into the melting process. In this study we investigate the first of these hypotheses, that source heterogeneity explains global Fe-Mg isotope systematics. We compile a global dataset of oceanic basalt Fe and Mg isotopes and complement this with new Fe-Mg isotope data from locations possessing some of the most extreme radiogenic isotope ratios for their setting: ocean island basalts from the Cook-Austral and Society islands and a Mid-Atlantic Ridge basalt. Despite both Fe and Mg isotope systems having the ability to trace recycled crustal material in the mantle, their global systematics are very different in this dataset. The global compilation of primitive oceanic basalts records heavier Fe (higher δ57 Fe) isotope compositions than bulk silicate earth (BSE), but a mixture of heavier and lighter Mg isotope compositions than BSE. By employing a coupled Fe-Mg equilibrium isotope fractionation model during mantle melting we show that much of this isotopic variability can be generated by the mixed melts produced by melting of peridotite mantle containing moderate amounts of recycled crust as a discrete lithology. The Fe isotope composition of the melts is controlled by the bulk isotope composition of the recycled crust (expected to be considerably heavier than BSE, but variable). In contrast, the Mg isotope composition is controlled by source mineralogy. Olivine-poor lithologies such as recycled crust are able to generate large Mg isotope fractionations during melting, both positive and negative (± 0.1‰) relative to the mantle source, depending on the presence of spinel, clinopyroxene or garnet. These melt Mg isotope fractionations are consistent with the Mg isotope compositions of mid-ocean ridge basalts generated by variable depths of mantle melting. Our equilibrium model provides a baseline to test hypotheses of Fe-Mg isotope variability in basalts: our results show that contributions from recycled crust-derived melts, generated in spinel-, pyroxene-, and garnet-bearing mineral assemblages in the mantle, would be able to produce much of the Fe-Mg isotope variability seen in the global compilation of primitive oceanic basalts, without requiring isotopically extreme mantle components (e.g., carbonate with a light Mg isotope signature) or disequilibrium fractionation. However some basalt variability in ocean island settings may indeed fall outside the paradigm of pyroxenite heterogeneity – whilst we consider carbonates unlikely to be important, disequilibrium processes may in these cases play a role.

The effect of diffusion on lithium isotope ratios in icelandic basalts

Deep neural network potentials for diffusional lithium isotope fractionation in silicate melts

Multi-mode Li Diffusion in Natural Zircons: Evidence for Diffusion in the Presence of Step-Function Concentration Boundaries

Discussion on Fractionation Mechanism of Lithiam Isotopes

Enormous Lithium Isotopic Variations of Abyssal Peridotites Reveal Fast Cooling and Melt/Fluid‐Rock Interactions

Diffusion-induced lithium isotopic heterogeneity in olivines from peridotites of an oceanized mantle lithosphere at the Yunzhug ophiolite (central Tibet)

Calcium isotope variability among ocean islands reveals the physical and lithological controls on mantle partial melting

Assessing hydrological controls on the lithium isotope weathering tracer

From Seawater Li Isotope Records to Carbon Cycle in Deep Time-Revisiting the Hydrothermal Control on Oceanic Li Isotope Mass Balance

Lithium Isotopic Compositions of Post-Collisional Mafic–ultramafic Rocks from Dabieshan, China: Implications for Recycling of Deeply Subducted Continental Crust

Global oceanic basalt sources and processes viewed through combined Fe and Mg stable isotopes

Sluggish Lithium Isotopic Response of Continental Intraplate Basalts to Recycled Sedimentary Carbonate

Lithium isotope evidence for subduction-enriched mantle in the source of mid-ocean-ridge basalts

Lithium Isotopic Geochemistry in Subduction Zones: Retrospects and Prospects

Chromium isotope fractionation during magmatic processes: Evidence from Mid-ocean ridge basalts

Experimental and theoretical constraints on lithium isotope fractionation during brine evaporation and halite precipitation

A brief review of isotopically light Li - a feature of the enriched mantle?

Fluid-rock Interaction Effects on Li Isotope Behavior in Continental Geothermal Systems

Magnesium isotopic variation of oceanic island basalts generated by partial melting and crustal recycling

Lithium Elemental and Isotopic Variations in Rock-Melt Interaction

Isotope Fractionation of Alkaline and Alkaline-Earth Elements (li, K, Rb, Mg, Ca, Sr, Ba) During Diffusion in Aqueous Solutions