What are the key influences and challenges around weight management faced by patients in UK adult secure mental health settings? A focused ethnographic approach

Susanna Mills,Eileen F S Kaner,Sheena E Ramsay,Iain McKinnon,Mills,S.,Kaner,E. F. S.,Ramsay,S. E.,McKinnon,I.

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-079406

IF: 3.006

2024-03-31

BMJ Open

Abstract:Objectives Excess weight is highly prevalent in secure (forensic) mental health services and impacts negatively on patients' physical and mental health. This study sought to identify the key influences and challenges around weight management in UK adult secure mental health settings. Design Qualitative focused ethnography. Analysis of written fieldnotes was undertaken through a combined inductive and deductive approach, informed by thematic analysis. Setting Low secure male mental health ward and associated patient activities and events, in a National Health Service Trust delivering mental health, intellectual disability and neurorehabilitation services in the UK. Participants 12 males (primarily white British) on the low secure ward; additional male participants from low and medium secure services, who took part in group events and activities; and multidisciplinary low and medium secure services staff. Approximately 23 hours of observation were undertaken over a 6-month period from April 2022. Results Secure mental healthcare delivered an environment predisposing patients to excessive weight gain and sedentary behaviour, which was often perceived as inevitable. Key themes highlighted the heightened salience of food in secure settings; inadequacy of catered hospital food and shortcomings of alternative food options; limited physical activity opportunities; and a ward culture that was not conducive to healthy behaviours. Perceptions and behaviour towards the ethnographer were primarily positive and accepting. Conclusions Weight management in secure services is a complex challenge. In future, whole setting-based interventions to promote healthy weight are likely to be required. These should integrate physical and mental health, incorporate underpinning determinants such as adequate staffing and a culture promoting weight management, and involve both patients and staff.

medicine, general & internal

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the key influencing factors and challenges of weight management faced by patients in secure mental health environments for adults in the UK. Specifically, the study aims to identify the factors leading to weight gain in these environments and how these factors affect the physical and mental health of patients.

### Research Background:
1. **Prevalence of Obesity and Overweight**: In the general population of the UK, 26% of adults are obese, and another 40% are overweight.
2. **Relationship Between Obesity and Mental Illness**: People with poor mental health are more likely to develop overweight and obesity, and vice versa. Particularly, individuals with severe mental illnesses (such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder) die 15-20 years earlier than the general population, mainly due to preventable physical health problems, especially non-communicable diseases caused by overweight and obesity.
3. **Challenges in Secure Care Environments**: Patients detained in secure care environments, due to criminal behavior or threats to themselves and others, cannot freely enter and exit medical institutions. In these environments, about 80% of patients have overweight issues.

### Research Objectives:
- **Identify Key Influencing Factors**: Explore the main factors leading to weight gain in secure care environments.
- **Identify Challenges**: Analyze the challenges faced in weight management in these environments.
- **Propose Solutions**: Based on the research findings, propose recommendations to improve weight management, including integrating physical and mental health, enhancing staff quality, and building a supportive culture.

### Research Methods:
- **Qualitative Focused Ethnography**: Gain in-depth understanding of the behaviors and perceptions of patients and staff through observation, interviews, and field notes.
- **Data Collection**: Conducted approximately 23 hours of observation over 6 months in a low-security male mental health ward.

### Key Findings:
1. **Importance of Food**: In secure care environments, food becomes an important means of socialization and interaction for patients.
2. **Poor Quality of Hospital-Provided Food**: Patients generally perceive the food provided by the hospital as poor quality, insufficient in quantity, and lacking in variety.
3. **Limited Alternative Food Choices**: Patients usually choose unhealthy foods when they go out.
4. **Lack of Opportunities for Physical Activity**: Due to the closed nature of the ward, patients have very limited opportunities to engage in physical activities.
5. **Ward Culture**: The culture and institutionalization of the ward lead to low concern among patients about personal appearance and weight.

### Conclusion:
Weight management in secure care environments is a complex challenge. Future interventions need to adopt a whole-environment approach to promote healthy weight, integrating physical and mental health, enhancing staff quality, and building a culture that supports weight management.