Abstract:Background and objective: Many countries have used the new ANACONDA (Analysis of Causes of National Death for Action) tool to assess the quality of their cause of death data (COD), but no cross-country analysis has been done to verify how different or similar patterns of diagnostic errors and data quality are in countries or how they are related to the local cultural or epidemiological environment or to levels of development. Our objective is to measure whether the usability of COD data and the patterns of unusable codes are related to a country's level of socio-economic development. Methods: We have assessed the quality of 20 national COD datasets from the WHO Mortality Database by assessing their completeness of COD reporting and the extent, pattern and severity of garbage codes, i.e. codes that provide little or no information about the true underlying COD. Garbage codes were classified into four groups based on the severity of the error in the code. The Vital Statistics Performance Index for Quality (VSPI(Q)) was used to measure the overall quality of each country's mortality surveillance system. Findings: The proportion of 'garbage codes' varied from 7 to 66% across the 20 countries. Countries with a high SDI generally had a lower proportion of high impact (i.e. more severe) garbage codes than countries with low SDI. While the magnitude and pattern of garbage codes differed among countries, the specific codes commonly used did not. Conclusions: There is an inverse relationship between a country's socio-demographic development and the overall quality of its cause of death data, but with important exceptions. In particular, some low SDI countries have vital statistics systems that are as reliable as more developed countries. However, in low-income countries, where most people die at home, the proportion of unusable codes often exceeds 50%, implying that half of all cause-specific mortality data collected is of little or no use in guiding public policy. Moreover, the cause of death pattern identified from the data is likely to seriously under-represent the true extent of the leading causes of death in the population, with very significant consequences for health priority setting. Garbage codes are prevalent at all ages, contrary to expectations. Further research into effective strategies deployed in these countries to improve data quality can inform efforts elsewhere to improve COD reporting systems.

Modeling causes of death: an integrated approach using CODEm

Joint models for cause-of-death mortality in multiple populations

Analyzing Cause-Specific Mortality Trends using Compositional Functional Data Analysis

Bayesian Hierarchical Factor Regression Models to Infer Cause of Death From Verbal Autopsy Data

Public health utility of cause of death data: applying empirical algorithms to improve data quality

BAYESIAN NESTED LATENT CLASS MODELS FOR CAUSE-OF-DEATH ASSIGNMENT USING VERBAL AUTOPSIES ACROSS MULTIPLE DOMAINS

Forecasting causes of death by using compositional data analysis: the case of cancer deaths

Estimating causes of maternal death in data‐sparse contexts

Multipopulation mortality modelling and forecasting: The multivariate functional principal component with time weightings approaches

Modeling Structure and Country-specific Heterogeneity in Misclassification Matrices of Verbal Autopsy-based Cause of Death Classifiers

A flexible Bayesian framework to estimate age- and cause-specific child mortality over time from sample registration data

Are cause of death data fit for purpose? evidence from 20 countries at different levels of socio-economic development

Public Health Informatics: Proposing Causal Sequence of Death Using Neural Machine Translation

Hierarchical Latent Class Models for Mortality Surveillance Using Partially Verified Verbal Autopsies

Proposing Causal Sequence of Death by Neural Machine Translation in Public Health Informatics

A Bayesian approach to estimate the completeness of death registration

InSilicoVA: A Method to Automate Cause of Death Assignment for Verbal Autopsy

Automated Extraction of Mortality Information from Publicly Available Sources Using Language Models

Model-Driven Decision Support: A Community-Based Meta-Implementation Strategy to Predict Population Impact

A novel approach to the cause of death identification—multi-strategy integration of multi-organ FTIR spectroscopy information using machine learning

Jointly Estimating Subnational Mortality for Multiple Populations