The likely role of urea in delaying the size at first maturity of ureosmotic Chondrichthyes

Melanie Warren,Daniel Pauly
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10641-024-01548-9
2024-04-25
Environmental Biology of Fishes
Abstract:The size—and hence the age—at first maturity is a very important feature of fish and other water-breathing ectotherms (WBE), as it determines, jointly with their subsequent growth, longevity, and fecundity, the reproductive output that their life-history attempts to optimize. Here, based on the fact that gill surface area ( S ) is related to their weight ( W ) according to S ∝ W d , with d always < 1, which causes relative oxygen supply to decline with size, and body fluids and tissues to gradually become hypercapnic and acidic, we posit that a pH "reproductive respiration threshold" (RRT) triggers the hormonal cascade leading to maturation. Previous studies showed that such a RRT exists and takes similar values in hundreds of species of bony fish and invertebrate WBE. Here, we show that the RRT is significantly lower in non-viviparous marine Chondrichthyes, as assessed based on 1622 pairs of length at first maturity and maximum length in 918 species of Chondrichthyes, i.e., 414 species of sharks, 470 of rays, and 34 of chimaera. The hypothesis that the high concentration of urea retained for the purpose of osmoregulation by marine Chondrichthyes is the reason for this difference was tested through comparison of marine, euryhaline, and freshwater rays, which retain differing urea concentrations. We found that in rays, decreasing urea retention correlates with increasing RRT, with freshwater rays approaching the values occurring in bony fish. Finally, we found that viviparity, which increases the oxygen demand of pregnant Chondrichthyes, induces higher RRT, thus again linking respiration and the attainment of first maturity. These results support the existence of critical maturation RRT, while also suggesting a role for urea that was previously undocumented.
ecology,marine & freshwater biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?