Cost–Benefit Analysis of Distributed Energy Systems Considering the Monetization of Indirect Benefits

Yutong Zhao,Shuang Zeng,Yifeng Ding,Lin Ma,Zhao Wang,Anqi Liang,Hongbo Ren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16020820

IF: 3.9

2024-01-18

Sustainability

Abstract:Driven by market value, a co-benefits assessment framework to encompass various benefits arising from distributed energy systems is developed. Using a monetization approach, a quantitative analysis model is established to evaluate both direct and indirect benefits. According to the simulation results of typical distributed energy systems, the distributed photovoltaic (PV) system demonstrates superior economic performance compared with the gas-fired distributed energy system, highlighting its potential for widespread commercialization. Moreover, the inclusion of indirect benefits significantly enhances the economic viability of the distributed energy system. While the PV system exhibits a more favorable promotional impact, it also renders the gas-fired distributed energy system commercially feasible.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper aims to address the issue of undervaluation of distributed energy systems (such as photovoltaic systems and gas distributed energy systems) during their practical implementation. Specifically, the authors propose a comprehensive evaluation framework to quantify the direct and indirect benefits of distributed energy systems and enhance their economic feasibility through monetization.

#### Main Contributions
1. **Comprehensive Evaluation Index System**: A comprehensive evaluation index system covering both direct and indirect benefits is proposed.
2. **Monetization Measures for Indirect Benefits**: Various non-market value assessment methods are proposed to measure various indirect benefits in monetary terms.

#### Methods and Analysis
1. **Evaluation Indicators and Methods**:
- Direct Economic Benefits (e.g., energy cost reduction): Evaluated through direct market methods.
- Environmental Benefits (e.g., carbon emission reduction): Monetized using current carbon market prices.
- Indirect benefits such as regional economic impact, risk avoidance, promotion incentives, and comfort improvement: Quantified using surrogate market methods and other non-market value assessment methods.

2. **Cost-Benefit Analysis Framework**:
- Combining direct and indirect benefits, a cost-benefit evaluation method is established to assess the overall economic value of distributed energy systems.

#### Numerical Analysis
1. **Research Object and Load Characteristics**:
- A residential community in Shanghai is selected as the research object, and the typical daily load characteristics in winter, summer, and transitional seasons are analyzed.
2. **Distributed Energy System Design**:
- The photovoltaic system and combined cooling, heating, and power (CCHP) system are examined, and the structure and operation modes of these two systems are described in detail.
3. **Parameter Settings**:
- Technical parameters, economic parameters, and relevant parameters required for the monetization of indirect benefits are set.

Through the above methods, the paper demonstrates that distributed energy systems not only have significant direct economic benefits but also considerable indirect benefits. Particularly, when indirect benefits are considered, the economic viability of photovoltaic systems becomes more prominent, and the gas distributed energy system also shows commercial feasibility.