Alex Gonzalez-Caceres,Franziska Hunger,Jens Forssén,Sanjay Somanath,Andreas Mark,Vasilis Naserentin,Joakim Bohlin,Anders Logg,Beata Wästberg,Dominika Komisarczyk,Fredrik Edelvik,Alexander Hollberg
Abstract:This work proposes an automated workflow using digital twinning for multi-domain environmental performance analysis of urban developments. Digital twins can potentially provide a common basis for multi-domain simulations and help overcome data availability and interoperability issues. The proposed workflow consists of five steps: (1) creating a procedural urban 3D model, (2) generating design alternatives parametrically, (3) exporting the context and each design alternative to each simulation tool, (4) running simulations for wind comfort, energy demand, and noise for each design alternative, and (5) combining and visualizing the simulation results using the digital twin. The workflow was applied to a neighbourhood in Sweden, the resultsreveal significant reduction in manual work when applying multiple simulation software for different domains. This is one step forward in streamlining the workflow for urban analysis, crucial for multi-domain optimization. In the future, further domains and simulation tools can be added to the workflow.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve
This paper aims to develop a multi-domain simulation workflow based on digital twin technology to optimize the environmental performance of urban design. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:
1. **Data Availability and Interoperability Issues**: Urban design involves simulation analyses in multiple domains, such as wind comfort, energy demand, and noise. These analyses often face difficulties in data acquisition and interoperability between different simulation tools. Digital twin technology can provide a unified data foundation to help overcome these issues.
2. **High Manual Workload**: Traditional multi-domain simulation workflows often require a significant amount of manual intervention, including data preparation, model generation, and result integration. This is not only time-consuming and labor-intensive but also prone to errors. The proposed workflow aims to automate this process, reducing the manual workload.
3. **Need for Multi-Domain Optimization**: Urban design needs to comprehensively consider multiple environmental factors, such as wind, energy efficiency, and noise. By integrating multiple simulation tools, this paper aims to achieve a comprehensive assessment and optimization of these factors, thereby providing more comprehensive support for urban design.
### Research Background
With the acceleration of urbanization, cities consume 78% of the world's energy and emit over 60% of greenhouse gases. Therefore, stakeholders in urban development need to intensify efforts in climate protection and adaptation, including reducing greenhouse gas emissions, enhancing urban resilience, and addressing climate change events. To achieve these goals, it is necessary to deeply understand how urban morphology and density affect factors such as temperature, wind, and noise, thereby optimizing the environmental performance of buildings.
### Problem Statement
The complex interactions in urban design make it crucial to simulate and evaluate different densification schemes to leverage potential benefits while limiting negative impacts. Currently, although there are many urban analysis tools, they usually cover only one or a few domains and require specific knowledge and complex calculations. Additionally, there are application barriers for computational fluid dynamics (CFD) in wind simulation and urban energy planning, and acoustic analysis is also a key factor in urban planning. Therefore, effective high-quality data exchange is needed to support multi-domain simulation analysis by different urban stakeholders.
### Research Objectives
The objective of this paper is to develop a simplified and coordinated workflow to optimize the environmental performance of urban design. The main research question is: How can digital twin technology be utilized to facilitate multi-domain urban environmental analysis to support design optimization?
### Methodology
The proposed workflow in this paper includes five steps:
1. **Generate 3D Urban Models**: Use data provided by the Swedish National Land Survey to generate urban geometry models.
2. **Generate Design Alternatives**: Randomly generate 7 different building layout schemes.
3. **Generate Inputs Required by Different Simulation Engines**: Ensure interoperability between different simulation tools.
4. **Conduct Simulations**: Perform simulations using wind simulation, energy simulation, and noise simulation tools.
5. **Combine, Visualize, and Evaluate Results**: Integrate and visualize the simulation results to evaluate the performance of different design schemes.
### Case Study
This paper selects a parking lot located in the city center of Gothenburg, Sweden, as the case area, which has the potential for central location and densification development. The total area of the study area is 11 hectares, but this paper only considers the currently unused part. By randomly generating 7 different design schemes, their performance in terms of wind comfort, energy demand, and noise levels is evaluated.
### Results
By analyzing the simulation results of different design schemes, this paper demonstrates the performance of each scheme in terms of wind comfort, energy demand, and noise levels. The results show that all schemes can reduce the area of low wind comfort to a certain extent, but have limited impact on surrounding buildings, streets, and places. In particular, some design schemes significantly improve wind comfort through reasonable building layouts, reducing the direct wind effect and the impact of downdrafts.