CPAP Versus NIPPV Postextubation in Preterm Neonates: A Comparative-Effectiveness Study
Amit Mukerji,Brooke Read,Junmin Yang,Michelle Baczynski,Eugene Ng,Michael Dunn,Guillaume Ethier,Ayman Abou Mehrem,Marc Beltempo,Christine Drolet,Orlando da Silva,Deepak Louis,Brigitte Lemyre,Jehier Afifi,Balpreet Singh,Rebecca Sherlock,Miroslav Stavel,Edith Masse,Jaideep Kanungo,Jonathan Wong,Jaya Bodani,Faiza Khurshid,Kyong-Soon Lee,Sajit Augustine,Caio Barbosa de Oliveira,Hala Makary,Alana Newman,Cecil Ojah,Prakesh S Shah,Prakesh S. Shah
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2023-064045
2024-03-21
PEDIATRICS
Abstract:BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES Nasal intermittent positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV) has been shown to be superior to nasal continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) postextubation in preterm neonates. However, studies have not permitted high CPAP pressures or rescue with other modes. We hypothesized that if CPAP pressures >8 cmH2O and rescue with other modes were permitted, CPAP would be noninferior to NIPPV. METHODS We conducted a pragmatic, comparative-effectiveness, noninferiority study utilizing network-based real-world data from 22 Canadian NICUs. Centers self-selected CPAP or NIPPV as their standard postextubation mode for preterm neonates <29 weeks’ gestation. The primary outcome was failure of the initial mode ≤72 hours. Secondary outcomes included failure ≤7 days, and reintubation ≤72 hours and ≤7 days. Groups were compared using a noninferiority adjusted risk-difference (aRD) margin of 0.05, and margin of no difference. RESULTS A total of 843 infants extubated to CPAP and 974 extubated to NIPPV were included. CPAP was not noninferior (and inferior) to NIPPV for failure of the initial mode ≤72 hours (33.0% vs 26.3%; aRD 0.07 [0.03 to 0.12], Pnoninferiority(NI) = .86), and ≤7 days (40.7% vs 35.8%; aRD 0.09 [0.05 to 0.13], PNI = 0.97). However, CPAP was noninferior (and equivalent) to NIPPV for reintubation ≤72 hours (13.2% vs 16.1%; aRD 0.01 [−0.05 to 0.02], PNI < .01), and noninferior (and superior) for reintubation ≤7 days (16.4% vs 22.8%; aRD −0.04 [−0.07 to −0.001], PNI < .01). CONCLUSIONS CPAP was not noninferior to NIPPV for failure ≤72 hours postextubation; however, it was noninferior to NIPPV for reintubation ≤72 hours and ≤7 days. This suggests CPAP may be a reasonable initial postextubation mode if alternate rescue strategies are available.
pediatrics