Abstract:The seabed community provides a sensitive litmus for environmental change. North Sea analysis of benthic populations provides an effective means for monitoring impacts from man's interventions, such as offshore oil exploitation and fishing, against baseline knowledge of the environment. Comparable knowledge of the benthic biology in the deep waters of the Atlantic Frontier beyond the N.E. Atlantic shelf edge is poorly developed. But uncertainties should not encourage assumptions and extrapolations from the better-known conditions on the continental shelf. While sampling at present still provides the best means to assess the health of the deepwater benthic habitat, protocols developed for deep-sea fauna should be applied. These are necessary because of (a) lower faunal densities, (b) higher species richness, (c) smaller body size, and (d) to ensure comparability with other deep-sea data. As in the North Sea, species richness and relative abundance can be analysed from quantitative samples in order to detect impacts. But analysis based on taxonomic sufficiency above species level is premature, even if arguably possible for coastal communities. Measures also need to ensure identifications are not forced to more familiar coastal species without proper study. Species-level analysis may be applied to seabed photographs of megafauna in relation to data on bottom environment, such as currents and the sediment, to monitor the health of the deep-water community. Although the composition of higher taxa in the benthic community is broadly similar to soft sediments on the shelf, concordance in sensitivities is speculative. Moreover, new organisms occur, such as giant protozoan xenophyophores, unknown on the continental shelf, whose sensitivities remain conjectural. Past knowledge of the benthic biology of the deep-water areas off Scotland is based on scattered stations and some more focussed, multidisciplinary studies, and should be significantly augmented by the results from the oil industry-funded Atlantic Margin Environmental Study cruises in 1996 and 1998. A predominantly depth-related pattern in variability applies here as found elsewhere in the deep ocean, and just sufficient knowledge-based predictive power exists to make comprehensive, high-resolution grid surveys unnecessary for the purpose of broad-scale environmental assessment. But new, small-scale site surveys remain necessary because of local-scale variability. Site survey should be undertaken in the context of existing knowledge of the deep sea in the UK area of the Atlantic Frontier and beyond, and can itself usefully be structured as tests of a projection from the regional scale to reduce sampling effort. It is to the benefit of all stakeholders that environmental assessment aspires to the highest scientific standards and contributes meaningfully to context knowledge. By doing so it will reduce uncertainties in future impact assessments and hence contribute usefully to environmental risk management.

Assessing Benthic Recovery Below the United Kingdom’s First Large‐Scale, Offshore, Longline Mussel Farm

Biogenic reef creation and biodiversity enhancement by an offshore longline mussel farm

Restorative function of offshore longline mussel farms with ecological benefits for commercial crustacean species

Integrating environmental and ecological monitoring with seaweed farming

Assessing the effects of salmon farming seabed enrichment using bacterial community diversity and high-throughput sequencing

Spatial and seasonal variability in benthic impact of mussel farms: Predicting and mitigating impacts using ambient oxygen conditions

Intensified Mussel Farming; Impacts on Nutrient Budgets and Ecology in a Eutrophic Semi‐enclosed Fjord System

Mussel farming impacts on trophic status and benthic community structure in Maliakos Gulf (Eastern Mediterranean)

Assessing the Efficacy of a Bouchot-Style Shellfish Reef as a Restoration Option in a Temperate Estuary

Salmon farming alters the structure and functioning of Norwegian maerl bed communities

A quantitative, non-destructive methodology for habitat characterisation and benthic monitoring at offshore renewable energy developments

Influence of Suspended Mussel Aquaculture and an Associated Invasive Ascidian on Benthic Macroinvertebrate Communities

Dislodgement and mortality challenges when restoring shallow mussel beds (Mytilus edulis) in a Danish estuary

Factors Affecting Benthic Impacts at Scottish Fish Farms

Habitat value of bivalve shellfish and seaweed aquaculture for fish and invertebrates: Pathways, synthesis and next steps

Comparison of Oyster Aquaculture Methods and Their Potential to Enhance Microbial Nitrogen Removal From Coastal Ecosystems

Macrobenthic fauna and the ecological status of a shellfish farm in the Mediterranean Sea (Algeria)

High-resolution fisheries data reveal effects of bivalve dredging on benthic communities in stressed coastal systems

Biomarkers of recovery: characterizing trophic flow following ecological restoration

Benthic impacts of fish farming: Meta-analysis of community and geochemical data

Deep-sea benthic community and environmental impact assessment at the Atlantic Frontier