Abstract:Guilt and compensation have long been research hotspots in the field of social emotions.Previous studies have mainly focused on how the prosocial attributes of guilt promote moral compensation and benefit victims.They have not thoroughly investigated how the guilt-induced compensation modulates moral transgressors'moral emotion and moral cognition.If guilt-induced compensation is solely aimed at compensating the victims,it would be equivalent for the transgressors whether the compensation to the victims comes from themselves or from a third-party.If compensation behaviour also has an impact on the transgressors themselves,third-party compensation would differ from self-compensation.To examine this issue,the present study investigates how moral compensation affects moral transgressors'moral emotions and moral perceptions through group-based guilt. Experiment 1(n=213)utilises a 2(Group:In-group vs.Out-group)x 3(Compensation Type:None-compensation vs.Third-party compensation vs.Self-compensation)within-subject design,employing a scenario imagination method to induce group-based guilt.Experiment 2(n=105)builds upon the first experiment by using a group-based interpersonal interaction paradigm to induce group-based guilt within a laboratory setting.Additionally,it quantifies the amounts of third-party and self-compensation to eliminate the potential confounding effect of compensation quantity.Experiment 3(n=128)further examined the stability of the results from Experiment 1 and Experiment 2 in non-collegiate population.The experimental designs of Experiments 2 and 3 are the same as those of Experiment 1. These three experiments consistently found that compared to the none-compensation condition,self-compensation significantly reduced group-based guilt and the perception of group-based responsibility,without inducing group-based shame.Third-party compensation also significantly reduced group-based guilt but to a lesser degree than self-compensation.At the same time,third-party compensation failed to reduce the perception of group-based responsibility and even elicited group-based shame.The differential impact of self-compensation and third-party compensation on guilt,responsibility,and shame suggests that guilt-induced compensation behaviour not only benefits the victims but also has positive effects on the transgressors themselves,serving as a form of self-regulation.Through compensation,transgressors can alleviate their feelings of guilt,reduce their sense of responsibility,and diminish the occurrence of shame. Previous research has predominantly regarded guilt as a negative emotion characterised by feelings of guilt and self-blame,emphasising its prosocial attributes towards victims while overlooking the potential benefits that transgressors may derive from guilt-induced prosocial behaviour.The present study suggests that compensatory behaviour triggered by guilt not only benefits the victims but also has a positive impact on the transgressors themselves,serving as a self-regulatory mechanism.Through compensation,transgressors can alleviate their feelings of guilt,reduce their sense of responsibility,and diminish the occurrence of shame.This finding demonstrates the dual effects of guilt,encompassing both concern and compensation towards victims as well as the regulation and restoration of one's own psychological state,thereby expanding our understanding of the prosocial attributes of guilt.

A mixed-methods systematic review of offence-related shame and/or guilt in violent offenders

The "common" experience of voice-hearing and its relationship with shame and guilt: a systematic review

Sexual Offending: Adverse Childhood Experiences, Shame, and Self-Compassion Explain the Variance in Self-Harm and Harm Towards Others?

A Systematic Review of Instruments to Assess Guilt in Children and Adolescents

Associations between humiliation, shame, self-harm and suicidality among adolescents and young adults: A systematic review

Guilt and Shame in Patients with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorders

Shame in patient‐health professional encounters: A scoping review

“Trapped in their Shame”: A Qualitative Investigation of Moral Injury in Forensic Psychiatry Patients

Guilt and shame: experiences of parents of self-harming adolescents

Interpersonal Trauma, Shame, and Substance Use: A Systematic Review

Guilt, Shame and Academic Misconduct

Impact of a group-based, compassion-focused treatment on shame and early life events among male prisoners

The shame of sexual violence towards women in rural areas

Shame and Self-Compassion Connect Childhood Experience of Adversity With Harm Inflicted on the Self and Others

Are self-conscious emotions about the self? Testing competing theories of shame and guilt across two disparate cultures.

Introducing the GASP scale: A new measure of guilt and shame proneness.

Childhood trauma and somatic symptoms among psychiatric outpatients: Investigating the role of shame and guilt

What will others think of me? The longitudinal association between trauma-related shame and guilt and psychopathology after a terror attack

The Effects of Compensatory Behaviour on Group-Based Guilt, Group-Based Responsibility, and Group-Based Shame in Moral Transgressors

Guilt, regret, and coping in individuals with obsessive–Compulsive disorder and individuals in conflict with law: A comparative study

The Psychosocial Consequences of Sexual Violence Stigma: A Scoping Review