Hedging Conditional Value at Risk with options

Maciej J. Capiński

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2014.11.011

IF: 6.4

2015-04-01

European Journal of Operational Research

Abstract:We present a method of hedging Conditional Value at Risk of a position in stock using put options. The result leads to a linear programming problem that can be solved to optimise risk hedging.

operations research & management science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Value-at-Risk constrained portfolios in incomplete markets: a dynamic programming approach to Heston's model

Marcos Escobar-Anel,Yevhen Havrylenko,Rudi Zagst

2024-07-30

Abstract:We solve an expected utility-maximization problem with a Value-at-risk constraint on the terminal portfolio value in an incomplete financial market due to stochastic volatility. To derive the optimal investment strategy, we use the dynamic programming approach. We demonstrate that the value function in the constrained problem can be represented as the expected modified utility function of a vega-neutral financial derivative on the optimal terminal wealth in the unconstrained utility-maximization problem. Via the same financial derivative, the optimal wealth and the optimal investment strategy in the constrained problem are linked to the optimal wealth and the optimal investment strategy in the unconstrained problem. In numerical studies, we substantiate the impact of risk aversion levels and investment horizons on the optimal investment strategy. We observe a 20% relative difference between the constrained and unconstrained allocations for average parameters in a low-risk-aversion short-horizon setting.

Portfolio Management,Optimization and Control
Hedged Monte-Carlo: low variance derivative pricing with objective probabilities

Marc Potters,Jean-Philippe Bouchaud,Dragan Sestovic

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4371%2800%2900554-9

2000-08-09

Abstract:We propose a new `hedged' Monte-Carlo (HMC) method to price financial derivatives, which allows to determine simultaneously the optimal hedge. The inclusion of the optimal hedging strategy allows one to reduce the financial risk associated with option trading, and for the very same reason reduces considerably the variance of our HMC scheme as compared to previous methods. The explicit accounting of the hedging cost naturally converts the objective probability into the `risk-neutral' one. This allows a consistent use of purely historical time series to price derivatives and obtain their residual risk. The method can be used to price a large class of exotic options, including those with path dependent and early exercise features.

Condensed Matter
Accelerated Portfolio Optimization with Conditional Value-at-Risk Constraints using a Cutting-Plane Method

Georg Hofmann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1408.2805

2014-08-12

Optimization and Control

Abstract:Financial portfolios are often optimized for maximum profit while subject to a constraint formulated in terms of the Conditional Value-at-Risk (CVaR). This amounts to solving a linear problem. However, in its original formulation this linear problem has a very large number of linear constraints, too many to be enforced in practice. In the literature this is addressed by a reformulation of the problem using so-called dummy variables. This reduces the large number of constraints in the original linear problem at the cost of increasing the number of variables. In the context of reinsurance portfolio optimization we observe that the increase in variable count can lead to situations where solving the reformulated problem takes a long time. Therefore we suggest a different approach. We solve the original linear problem with cutting-plane method: The proposed algorithm starts with the solution of a relaxed problem and then iteratively adds cuts until the solution is approximated within a preset threshold. This is a new approach. For a reinsurance case study we show that a significant reduction of necessary computer resources can be achieved.
Construction and Hedging of Equity Index Options Portfolios

Maciej Wysocki,Robert Ślepaczuk

2024-07-19

Abstract:This research presents a comprehensive evaluation of systematic index option-writing strategies, focusing on S&P500 index options. We compare the performance of hedging strategies using the Black-Scholes-Merton (BSM) model and the Variance-Gamma (VG) model, emphasizing varying moneyness levels and different sizing methods based on delta and the VIX Index. The study employs 1-minute data of S&P500 index options and index quotes spanning from 2018 to 2023. The analysis benchmarks hedged strategies against buy-and-hold and naked option-writing strategies, with a focus on risk-adjusted performance metrics including transaction costs. Portfolio delta approximations are derived using implied volatility for the BSM model and market-calibrated parameters for the VG model. Key findings reveal that systematic option-writing strategies can potentially yield superior returns compared to buy-and-hold benchmarks. The BSM model generally provided better hedging outcomes than the VG model, although the VG model showed profitability in certain naked strategies as a tool for position sizing. In terms of rehedging frequency, we found that intraday hedging in 130-minute intervals provided both reliable protection against adverse market movements and a satisfactory returns profile.

Portfolio Management,Risk Management,Trading and Market Microstructure
Optimal inventory and hedging decisions with CVaR consideration

weili xue,lijun ma,houcai shen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2015.01.011

IF: 11.251

2015-01-01

International Journal of Production Economics

Abstract:We consider a newsvendor who makes an ordering decision to meet stochastic demand and buys a put option written on the demand to hedge against the risk of low demand to maximize his expected utility, which is measured by the conditional value-at-risk (CVaR). The put option is fairly priced with specifications for the strike price and the strike quantity. With the consideration of lost-sale penalty cost, we derive structural results on the optimal ordering and hedging polices. We show that the newsvendor will not order more than that without the option contract when the strike quantity is pre-determined and low, and he will order more when the strike quantity is a decision variable. Moreover, the optimal strike quantity is less than or equal to the optimal order quantity in the risk-neutral setting, and interestingly there are cases in which the optimal hedging ratio first increases, then keeps constant as the newsvendor becomes less risk averse. We also show that the value of the put option increases as the newsvendor becomes more risk averse and demand becomes more uncertain. Furthermore, the effect of risk aversion on the value of the option highly depends on the magnitudes of the system parameters.
Hedging Production Risk With Options

Yong Sakong,Dermot J. Hayes,Arne Hallam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/1242925

IF: 3.757

1993-05-01

American Journal of Agricultural Economics

Abstract:Abstract The expected utility maximization problem is solved for producers with both price and production uncertainty who have access to both futures and options markets. Introduction of production uncertainty alters the optimal futures and options position and almost always makes it optimal for the producer to purchase put options and to underhedge on the futures market. Simulation results lend support to the practice of hedging the minimum expected yield on the futures market and hedging remaining expected production against downside price risk using put options. The results are strengthened if the producer expects local production to influence national prices and if risk aversion is higher at low income levels.
Portfolio Optimization Managing Value at Risk under Heavy Tail Return, using Stochastic Maximum Principle

Subhojit Biswas,Mrinal K.Ghosh,Diganta Mukherjee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1908.03905

2020-12-01

Abstract:We consider an investor, whose portfolio consists of a single risky asset and a risk free asset, who wants to maximize his expected utility of the portfolio subject to managing the Value at Risk (VaR) assuming a heavy tailed distribution of the stock prices return. We use a stochastic maximum principle to formulate the dynamic optimisation problem. The equations which we obtain does not have any explicit analytical solution, so we look for accurate approximations to estimate the value function and optimal strategy. As our calibration strategy is non-parametric in nature, no prior knowledge on the form of the distribution function is needed. We also provide detailed empirical illustration using real life data. Our results show close concordance with financial <a class="link-external link-http" href="http://intuition.We" rel="external noopener nofollow">this http URL</a> expect that our results will add to the arsenal of the high frequency traders.

Portfolio Management,Mathematical Finance
The Value of Timing Risk

Jiro Akahori,Flavia Barsotti,Yuri Imamura

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1701.05695

2017-01-20

Abstract:The aim of this paper is to provide a mathematical contribution on the semi-static hedge of timing risk associated to positions in American-style options under a multi-dimensional market model. Barrier options are considered in the paper and semi-static hedges are studied and discussed for a fairly large class of underlying price dynamics. Timing risk is identified with the uncertainty associated to the time at which the payoff payment of the barrier option is due. Starting from the work by Carr and Picron (1999), where the authors show that the timing risk can be hedged via static positions in plain vanilla options, the present paper extends the static hedge formula proposed in Carr and Picron (1999) by giving sufficient conditions to decompose a generalized timing risk into an integral of knock-in options in a multi-dimensional market model. A dedicated study of the semi-static hedge is then conducted by defining the corresponding strategy based on positions in barrier options. The proposed methodology allows to construct not only first order hedges but also higher order semi-static hedges, that can be interpreted as asymptotic expansions of the hedging error. The convergence of these higher order semi-static hedges to an exact hedge is shown. An illustration of the main theoretical results is provided for i) a symmetric case, ii) a one dimensional case, where the first order and second order hedging errors are derived in analytic closed form. The materiality of the hedging benefit gain of going from order one to order two by re-iterating the timing risk hedging strategy is discussed through numerical evidences by showing that order two can bring to more than 90% reduction of the hedging 'cost' w.r.t. order one (depending on the specific barrier option characteristics).

Pricing of Securities
Robust Risk-Aware Option Hedging

David Wu,Sebastian Jaimungal

2023-12-27

Abstract:The objectives of option hedging/trading extend beyond mere protection against downside risks, with a desire to seek gains also driving agent's strategies. In this study, we showcase the potential of robust risk-aware reinforcement learning (RL) in mitigating the risks associated with path-dependent financial derivatives. We accomplish this by leveraging a policy gradient approach that optimises robust risk-aware performance criteria. We specifically apply this methodology to the hedging of barrier options, and highlight how the optimal hedging strategy undergoes distortions as the agent moves from being risk-averse to risk-seeking. As well as how the agent robustifies their strategy. We further investigate the performance of the hedge when the data generating process (DGP) varies from the training DGP, and demonstrate that the robust strategies outperform the non-robust ones.

Computational Finance,Machine Learning,Risk Management
Option Dynamic Hedging Using Reinforcement Learning

Cong Zheng,Jiafa He,Can Yang

2023-06-19

Abstract:This work focuses on the dynamic hedging of financial derivatives, where a reinforcement learning algorithm is designed to minimize the variance of the delta hedging process. In contrast to previous research in this area, we apply uncertainty estimation technology to measure the uncertainty of the agent's decision, which can further reduce unnecessary wear and tear in the hedging process and control model overconfidence that may lead to significant losses. Numerical experiments show the superiority of our strategy in Monte Carlo simulations and SP 500 option data.

Optimization and Control
Option Hedging with Risk Averse Reinforcement Learning

Edoardo Vittori,Michele Trapletti,Marcello Restelli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.12245

2020-10-23

Trading and Market Microstructure

Abstract:In this paper we show how risk-averse reinforcement learning can be used to hedge options. We apply a state-of-the-art risk-averse algorithm: Trust Region Volatility Optimization (TRVO) to a vanilla option hedging environment, considering realistic factors such as discrete time and transaction costs. Realism makes the problem twofold: the agent must both minimize volatility and contain transaction costs, these tasks usually being in competition. We use the algorithm to train a sheaf of agents each characterized by a different risk aversion, so to be able to span an efficient frontier on the volatility-p\&l space. The results show that the derived hedging strategy not only outperforms the Black \& Scholes delta hedge, but is also extremely robust and flexible, as it can efficiently hedge options with different characteristics and work on markets with different behaviors than what was used in training.
On the shortfall risk control -- a refinement of the quantile hedging method

Michał Barski

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/strm-2014-1169

2015-12-10

Abstract:The issue of constructing a risk minimizing hedge under an additional almost-surely type constraint on the shortfall profile is examined. Several classical risk minimizing problems are adapted to the new setting and solved. In particular, the bankruptcy threat of optimal strategies appearing in the classical risk minimizing setting is ruled out. The existence and concrete forms of optimal strategies in a general semimartingale market model with the use of conditional statistical tests are proven. The well known quantile hedging method as well as the classical Neyman-Pearson lemma are generalized. Optimal hedging strategies with shortfall constraints in the Black-Scholes and exponential Poisson model are explicitly determined.

Pricing of Securities,Optimization and Control
Toward an efficient hybrid method for pricing barrier options on assets with stochastic volatility

Alexander Lipton,Artur Sepp

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2202.07849

2022-02-16

Abstract:We combine the one-dimensional Monte Carlo simulation and the semi-analytical one-dimensional heat potential method to design an efficient technique for pricing barrier options on assets with correlated stochastic volatility. Our approach to barrier options valuation utilizes two loops. First we run the outer loop by generating volatility paths via the Monte Carlo method. Second, we condition the price dynamics on a given volatility path and apply the method of heat potentials to solve the conditional problem in closed-form in the inner loop. We illustrate the accuracy and efficacy of our semi-analytical approach by comparing it with the two-dimensional Monte Carlo simulation and a hybrid method, which combines the finite-difference technique for the inner loop and the Monte Carlo simulation for the outer loop. We apply our method for computation of state probabilities (Green function), survival probabilities, and values of call options with barriers. Our approach provides better accuracy and is orders of magnitude faster than the existing methods. s a by-product of our analysis, we generalize Willard's (1997) conditioning formula for valuation of path-independent options to path-dependent options and derive a novel expression for the joint probability density for the value of drifted Brownian motion and its running minimum.

Computational Finance
Optimal Static Quadratic Hedging

Tim Leung,Matthew Lorig

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1506.02074

2015-11-19

Abstract:We propose a flexible framework for hedging a contingent claim by holding static positions in vanilla European calls, puts, bonds, and forwards. A model-free expression is derived for the optimal static hedging strategy that minimizes the expected squared hedging error subject to a cost constraint. The optimal hedge involves computing a number of expectations that reflect the dependence among the contingent claim and the hedging assets. We provide a general method for approximating these expectations analytically in a general Markov diffusion market. To illustrate the versatility of our approach, we present several numerical examples, including hedging path-dependent options and options written on a correlated asset.

Mathematical Finance
Discrete time portfolio optimisation managing value at risk under heavy tail return distribution

Subhojit Biswas,Diganta Mukherjee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1908.03907

2020-12-01

Abstract:We consider an investor, whose portfolio consists of a single risky asset and a risk free asset, who wants to maximize his expected utility of the portfolio subject to the Value at Risk assuming a heavy tail distribution of the stock prices return. We use Markov Decision Process and dynamic programming principle to get the optimal strategies and the value function which maximize the expected utility for parametric as well as non parametric distributions. Due to lack of explicit solution in the non parametric case, we use numerical integration for optimization

Portfolio Management,Mathematical Finance
Hedging under rough volatility

Masaaki Fukasawa,Blanka Horvath,Peter Tankov

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2105.04073

2021-05-10

Abstract:In this chapter we first briefly review the existing approaches to hedging in rough volatility models. Next, we present a simple but general result which shows that in a one-factor rough stochastic volatility model, any option may be perfectly hedged with a dynamic portfolio containing the underlying and one other asset such as a variance swap. In the final section we report the results of a back-test experiment using real data, where VIX options are hedged with a forward variance swap. In this experiment, using a rough volatility model allows to almost completely remove the bias and reduce the overall hedging error by a factor of 27% compared to traditional diffusion-based models.

Mathematical Finance
Hedging The Risk In The Continuous Time Option Pricing Model With Stochastic Stock Volatility

D. F. Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/9807066

1998-07-05

Abstract:In this work, I address the issue of forming riskless hedge in the continuous time option pricing model with stochastic stock volatility. I show that it is essential to verify whether the replicating portfolio is self-financing, in order for the theory to be self-consistent. The replicating methods in existing finance literature are shown to violate the self-financing constraint when the underlying asset has stochastic volatility. Correct self-financing hedge is formed in this article.

Statistical Mechanics,Pricing of Securities
Option-Based Pricing of Wrong Way Risk for CVA

Chris Kenyon,Andrew Green

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1609.00819

2021-10-09

Abstract:The two main issues for managing wrong way risk (WWR) for the credit valuation adjustment (CVA, i.e. WW-CVA) are calibration and hedging. Hence we start from a novel model-free worst-case approach based on static hedging of counterparty exposure with liquid options. We say "start from" because we demonstrate that a naive worst-case approach contains hidden unrealistic assumptions on the variance of the hazard rate (i.e. that it is infinite). We correct this by making it an explicit (finite) parameter and present an efficient method for solving the parametrized model optimizing the hedges. We also prove that WW-CVA is theoretically, but not practically, unbounded. The option-based hedges serve to significantly reduce (typically halve) practical WW-CVA. Thus we propose a realistic and practical option-based worst case CVA.

Pricing of Securities,Computational Finance,Mathematical Finance,Risk Management
Integrated Capacity and Exchange Rate Hedging in Multi-Markets under Value-at-Risk

Jian Chen,Qing Ding,Long Ren,Jing-Sheng Jeannette Song

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.4359370

2023-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We consider the optimal integrated capacity and financial hedging strategies for a downside risk-averse global firm that faces multiple demand and foreign exchange rate risks. The firm maximizes the expected profit while controlling its profit-risk through a Value-at-Risk (VaR) constraint, which ensures the probability of the realized profit below a profit reservation level is within tolerance. A breakthrough of our research is to identify a tractable approach to resolving the well-known challenging VaR constraint. This approach allows us to consider multiple foreign markets instead of only a single foreign market under other risk measures typically assumed in the literature. We characterize efficient financial hedging under any given capacity in a general form that can be replicated with vanilla derivatives, making the profit reservation level and tolerance level interchangeable. Using this fact, we show that the optimal capacity is either the risk-neutral solution or on the boundary of the feasible region, in contrast to the mean-variance framework where multiple solutions may occur for multi-markets. We demonstrate that operational and financial hedging can be either substitutes or complements, depending on the hedging scenario.
Solving the Value-at-risk Minimisation Model with Linear Programming Techniques

Chunhui Xu,Xiaolin Huang,Yanli Huo,Shuning Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1504/ajmsa.2016.10001348

2016-01-01

Abstract:This study considers portfolio selection problems in which risk is measured using value-at-risk (VaR). Because VaR is generally a non-convex and non-smooth function, conventional optimisation methods fail to solve portfolio selection models based on VaR. This has been considered an open problem since the 1990s. The study first proves that VaR is a continuous piecewise linear function of position when it is estimated with the scenario simulation method, and then, proposes a method for solving VaR minimisation models. The proposed method can yield a good local minimum or even a global optimum, although it has no theoretical guarantee. Because the proposed method uses only linear programming techniques, common linear programming solution software can be employed to solve VaR minimisation models of practical sizes in a short period of time. To illustrate the performance of the proposed method, we use it to solve a VaR minimisation model with 30 equities and 1,000 scenarios. We also compare the precision and computing time with another method. The results show that both methods can yield the optimal solution, but the proposed method is much faster.

Hedging Conditional Value at Risk with options

Value-at-Risk constrained portfolios in incomplete markets: a dynamic programming approach to Heston's model

Hedged Monte-Carlo: low variance derivative pricing with objective probabilities

Accelerated Portfolio Optimization with Conditional Value-at-Risk Constraints using a Cutting-Plane Method

Construction and Hedging of Equity Index Options Portfolios

Optimal inventory and hedging decisions with CVaR consideration

Hedging Production Risk With Options

Portfolio Optimization Managing Value at Risk under Heavy Tail Return, using Stochastic Maximum Principle

The Value of Timing Risk

Robust Risk-Aware Option Hedging

Option Dynamic Hedging Using Reinforcement Learning

Option Hedging with Risk Averse Reinforcement Learning

On the shortfall risk control -- a refinement of the quantile hedging method

Toward an efficient hybrid method for pricing barrier options on assets with stochastic volatility

Optimal Static Quadratic Hedging

Discrete time portfolio optimisation managing value at risk under heavy tail return distribution

Hedging under rough volatility

Hedging The Risk In The Continuous Time Option Pricing Model With Stochastic Stock Volatility

Option-Based Pricing of Wrong Way Risk for CVA

Integrated Capacity and Exchange Rate Hedging in Multi-Markets under Value-at-Risk

Solving the Value-at-risk Minimisation Model with Linear Programming Techniques