Temporal negotiations and injustices in the energy transition: Perspectives from a Spanish coal region

Alexia Sanz-Hernández

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2024.103453

IF: 8.514

2024-02-04

Energy Research & Social Science

Abstract:The academic literature on energy transition often overlooks temporal dynamics. This study focuses on a traditional coal region in Spain, analyzing the temporal negotiation and confrontation processes that occur during coal phase-out, designed to expedite the energy transition. By examining 821 news articles from regional newspapers through discourse analysis, it assesses the actors involved, the influencing factors on temporal control (duration, pace, and trajectories), and the outcomes of temporal negotiation (interactional achievements). The key findings reveal tensions between differing perspectives on duration and pace, as well as conflicts between government management and local actors' demands regarding transition trajectories. Local actors perceive the coal phase-out as a lengthy, distressing, and unjust process primarily driven by the government and energy corporations. Despite the implementation of Just Transition Agreements (JTAs) aimed at involving affected communities and territories in shaping the energy transition's future scenarios, local actors have limited participation in deciding transition timelines. Instead, JTAs function as a tool for temporal governance that subtly perpetuates compensatory and continuist policies from the past. They promote resignation among the population and instill a sense of inevitability regarding certain strategic alternatives. In conclusion, the study reveals temporal injustices and tensions between the acceleration of the transition and the deceleration of territorial development after the phase-out of coal. It underscores that the construction of transformative local future scenarios necessitates considering local actors' perspectives and demands, not only in the careful planning of transition trajectories but also in addressing the duration and pace of the Just Transition.

environmental studies