Abstract:The Kalman filter is an established tool for the analysis of dynamic systems with normally distributed noise, and it has been successfully applied in numerous application areas. It provides sequentially calculated estimates of the system states along with a corresponding covariance matrix. For nonlinear systems, the extended Kalman filter is often used which is derived from the Kalman filter by linearization around the current estimate. A key issue in metrology is the evaluation of the uncertainty associated with the Kalman filter state estimates. The "Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurements" (GUM) and its supplements serve as the de facto standard for uncertainty evaluation in metrology. We explore the relationship between the covariance matrix produced by the Kalman filter and a GUM-compliant uncertainty analysis. In addition, also the results of a Bayesian analysis are considered. For the case of linear systems with known system matrices, we show that all three approaches are compatible. When the system matrices are not precisely known, however, or when the system is nonlinear, this equivalence breaks down and different results can be reached then. Though for precisely known nonlinear systems the result of the extended Kalman filter still corresponds to the linearized uncertainty propagation of GUM. The extended Kalman filter can suffer from linearization and convergence errors. These disadvantages can be avoided to some extent by applying Monte Carlo procedures, and we propose such a method which is GUM-compliant and can also be applied online during the estimation. We illustrate all procedures in terms of a two-dimensional dynamic system and compare the results with those obtained by particle filtering, which has been proposed for the approximate calculation of a Bayesian solution. Finally, we give some recommendations based on our findings.

From Univariate to Multivariate Uncertainty Calculation

On a Monte Carlo method for measurement uncertainty evaluation and its implementation

A brief guide to measurement uncertainty (IUPAC Technical Report)

Getting started with uncertainty evaluation using the Monte Carlo method in R

Application of Monte Carlo Method in the Measurement Process Design According to Next Generation of Gps

Monte Carlo uncertainty estimation for wavelength calibration

Unified Reliability Measure Method Considering Uncertainties of Input Variables and Their Distribution Parameters

Mathematical modeling applied to the uncertainty analysis of a tank prover calibration: Understanding the influence of calibration conditions on the GUM validation using the Monte Carlo method

A Pilot Study of Multivariate Uncertainty Theory

Random Fuzzy Extension of the Universal Generating Function Approach for the Reliability Assessment of Multi-State Systems under Aleatory and Epistemic Uncertainties

Hybrid universal generating function for the reliability assessment of multi-state systems under aleatory and epistemic uncertainties

On the evaluation of uncertainties for state estimation with the Kalman filter

A self-adaptive method for the assessment of dynamic measurement uncertainty

The use of a Monte Carlo method for uncertainty calculation, with an application to the measurement of neutron ambient dose equivalent rate

Unified Uncertainty Analysis By The Extension Universal Generating Functions

Uncertainty Evaluation for a Three Dimensional Rotary Measuring System by Markov Chain Monte Carlo Method

Unified Uncertainties: Combining Input, Data and Model Uncertainty into a Single Formulation

Use of the Monte Carlo method for the estimation of measurement uncertainty in chemical analysis systems with intensive mathematical treatment

Multivariate regression and fit function uncertainty

A practical two-step procedure for taking into account all available information (prior and current) about influence quantities in measurement uncertainty analysis

Determination of measurement uncertainty by Monte Carlo simulation