Network Connection Issues in ADHD

Katya Rubia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.20240319

IF: 17.7

2024-06-02

American Journal of Psychiatry

Abstract:The past three decades of structural and functional MRI (fMRI) studies have contributed to the current view that attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a neurodevelopmental disorder, characterized by differences in the underlying brain structure, function, and structural and functional connectivity (1, 2). The most consistently found brain differences are in frontal, temporal, parietal, and striatal regions or networks that mediate higher-level attention and cognitive control functions that are often impaired in ADHD (1–4). More recently, in large-scale MRI mega- and meta-analyses (3, 4), affective regions such as amygdala and associated fronto-limbic regions have also been found to be different in structure, parallel to the increased awareness of affective behavior traits in the disorder, such as emotional dysregulation mediated by these areas (1). A key flaw of MRI studies in ADHD, as in other psychiatric disorders, is the inclusion of small numbers of participants, which has likely contaminated the field with false positives and inflated the effect sizes of nonreproducible brain differences (5, 6). This applies, in particular, to the majority of functional connectivity fMRI studies in ADHD, which have had small samples and highly heterogeneous analytical methods, resulting in inconsistent and likely inflated findings with respect to location and direction of network differences, such as increased, decreased, or no differing resting-state and task-based functional connectivity in participants with ADHD (7–9). This problem is addressed by Norman et al. in this issue of Journal (10), in a much-needed large-scale mega-analysis of resting-state functional connectivity data in 8,442 participants with and without ADHD, collected across multiple centers in the United States.

psychiatry