Abstract:Operating room (OR) managers must plan staffing in the face of uncertain demand for OR time. Planning too much staffing results in underutilized OR time. Planning too little staffing causes overutilized time, which is approximately twice as expensive as underutilized time. Deciding how much staffing to plan for an OR is analogous to the classic newsvendor problem in operations research. A newsvendor must decide how much product to order based on its cost c and sales price p, plus estimates of the uncertain future demand for the product. The newsvendor problem has a simple mathematical solution. The correct amount of product to order is the (p - c)/p quantile of the demand for the product. This optimal order quantity is analogous mathematically to the number of hours of OR time for which staffing should be planned. We performed a systematic review of the behavioral operations experimental literature on newsvendor problems relevant to OR management. Student volunteers participating in experimental studies have great difficulty knowing how much product to order, given c, p, and the demand distribution. Decision making is only modestly improved by more frequent feedback. Even scores of rounds of ordering are insufficient for much learning to occur. Suboptimal decisions result from innate psychological biases. Students anchor on mean demand, make insufficient adjustments, and rely disproportionately on the most recent demand values. The behavior of OR managers who plan staffing for the OR is analogous to that of students participating in a newsvendor experiment. Month after month, an OR manager will plan too little staffing for the surgeon who consistently ends the day late and too much staffing for the surgeon who consistently does not fill an OR. Experimental studies of the newsvendor problem provide mechanistic insights into the reasons that OR managers make poor decisions when planning OR staffing. The students face no organizational factors or personality issues that potentially influence OR managers, strongly suggesting that observed psychological biases are innate and play an important role in influencing the decisions of OR managers. Results suggest that only the use of computerized decision-support systems can effectively circumvent these biases.

Managing variability in perioperative services

Re-engineering the operating room using variability methodology to improve health care value

Surgery Scheduling Optimization Considering Real Life Constraints and Comprehensive Operation Cost of Operating Room

Evaluating the Impact of the Level of Robustness in Operating Room Scheduling Problems

The Timing of Staffing Decisions in Hospital Operating Rooms: Incorporating Workload Heterogeneity into the Newsvendor Problem

Retrospective Analysis of Associated Costs and Sources of Variability in OR Utilization Across Weekdays

Surgical unit time utilization review: Resource utilization and management implications

In a high volume orthopaedic unit, managing natural variability and utilising the theory of constraints improves surgical throughput.

Management of Common Postoperative Complications

The Power Law in Operating Room Management

Optimizing Throughput in Clinical Practice: Lean Management and Efficient Care in Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery

Current Trends in Operating Room Scheduling 2015 to 2020: a Literature Review

Optimizing Nurse Scheduling: A Supply Chain Approach for Healthcare Institutions

Hospital-Wide Inpatient Flow Optimization

Review article: review of behavioral operations experimental studies of newsvendor problems for operating room management

Multi-objective stochastic scheduling of inpatient and outpatient surgeries

Analysis of uncertainty in the surgical department: durations, requests, and cancellations

Scheduling elective and emergency surgeries at shared operating rooms with emergency uncertainty and waiting time limit

The uncertain surgery time in integrated sequencing, planning and scheduling problem of the surgical ward

Surgery Scheduling under Case Cancellation and Surgery Duration Uncertainty.

Variation in pediatric surgical care