Exercise Therapy for Post–COVID-19 Condition
Peter Ladlow,Alexander N. Bennett,Oliver O’Sullivan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.6959
2024-04-05
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:International guidelines from public health organizations, including the World Health Organization, caution against graded exercise for treating patients with postexertional symptom exacerbation (PESE), a commonly reported feature of post–COVID-19 condition (PCC). These recommendations are provided despite the well-documented deleterious effects of physical inactivity and its close association with secondary health conditions and deterioration in quality of life. Subsequently, there has been confusion and reluctance among health care practitioners to prescribe exercise-based rehabilitation to individuals with PCC to avoid the debilitating effects of postexertional malaise, fatigue, or PESE. Consequently, the effects of exercise-based rehabilitation for individuals with persistent PESE remain poorly understood. Studies have shown that among individuals with PCC, up to 48% of female individuals and 41% of male individuals experience postexertional malaise, and 29% of female individuals and 28% of male individuals experience orthostatic intolerance. 1 The article by Tryfonos and colleagues 2 is, therefore, timely and necessary because it addresses an important topic in the debate surrounding patient acceptability and the therapeutic effects of different exercise modalities in the treatment of patients with PCC and their acute risks of developing PESE. Tryfonos et al 2 recruited 31 nonhospitalized, community-based participants with a mean (SD) symptom duration of 21.6 (9.2) months following COVID-19 illness (with 31 age-matched and sex-matched healthy controls for comparison). This previously healthy and working-age population represents an important section of society; 78% of the PCC group were employed full-time before SARS-CoV-2 infection. Subsequently, 74% had to take sick leave lasting longer than 12 months. PCC, therefore, has a substantial economic impact on nonhospitalized, working-aged individuals, a challenge that is magnified if job roles are cognitively and/or physically demanding. 3 The careful introduction and future management of exercise therapy in the treatment of individuals with postviral conditions has been previously proposed following a comprehensive needs analysis to mitigate PESE. 4 This can be achieved by individually tailoring exercise prescription and/or management and incorporating both resistance exercise and cardiorespiratory fitness, in an approach termed symptom-guided exercise rehabilitation . 4 Testing this theory, Tryfonos and colleagues 2 monitored the acute effects of 3 different types of exercise stimulus in those with PESE, compared with healthy controls, aware that patients with PCC spent 43% less time in moderate-to-vigorous physical activity compared with controls (approximately 26.5 minutes per day). The 3 exercise modalities were (1) high-intensity interval training (HIIT), (2) moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT), and strength-based training (ST) performed in a randomized, crossover design with 2 to 4 weeks of washout between sessions. The primary outcome measure was the difference in fatigue level (from baseline to 48 hours after exercise) between groups. The authors chose this time, citing that those with phenotypically similar myalgic encephalomyelitis–chronic fatigue syndrome commonly report PESE between 24 and 72 hours after exertion. Reassuringly, there were no between-group differences in fatigue 48 hours after any exercise modality (HIIT, MICT, or ST). However, subtle differences in self-reported symptoms were observed following each exercise condition, with patients with PCC reporting higher levels of concentration impairment following MICT and greater increases in muscle soreness after ST (commensurate with delayed onset of muscle soreness, which is expected after completing unfamiliar loaded resistance exercise). Compared with healthy controls, the PCC group had higher overall self-reported symptom scores at all time points (before exercise, immediately after exercise, and at 48 hours follow-up) alongside substantial physiological characteristics; indeed, a particular strength of this study 2 is the range of physiological assessments undertaken. The PCC group demonstrated underlying dysfunction in multiple organ systems that may contribute to activity limitations, including muscular impairment (ie, higher incidence of myogenic-derived myopathies observed alongside decreased isometric muscle strength), indices of orthostatic intolerance, lower peak and submaximal aerobic capacity (ie, maximal oxygen consumption at peak and ventilatory threshold), lower heart rate variability (recorded during deep breathing), higher resting heart rate, and increased arterial stiffness. Tryfonos et al 2 proposed mechanisms, including physical inactivity, peripheral tissue damage, and/or neurophysiological changes, for these -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal