Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and environmental temperature

C. Bacon

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5694/j.1326-5377.1990.tb125230.x

1990-04-01

Abstract:11M 7.5 +++ 4.21 0.98 0.42 21M 5 ++ 5.3 1.45 0.42 3/F 9 +++ 8.7 0.92 0.42 4/M 2.5 ++ + 6.7 1.4 0.61 5/F 4 ++ 1.32 0.7 0.41 6/F 3 + 4.53 0.29 0.41 71M 7 weeks +++ +++ 5.0 0.98 0.42 8/F 5 weeks +++ +++ 6.53 1.25 0.64 9/M 2 +++ Serum haemolysed 101M 1.5 ++ +++ 6.2 1.25 0.51 11/F 14 +++ 4.53 0.5 0.41 ance on inductive logic. Inductive logic has been an unforgivable sin of philosophy since its hazards were described by the scientific philosopher David Hume in the mid-18th Century. To illustrate this point, I would like to recount Alan Chalmer's elaboration of Bertrand Russell's story of the inductivist turkey.' This turkey found that, on his first morning at a turkey farm he was fed at 9 a.m. However, being a good inductivist he did not jump to conclusions. He waited until he had collected a large number of observations to the fact that he was fed at 9 a.m. and he made these observations under a wide variety of circumstances on Wednesdays, on Thursdays, on warm days, on cold days, on rainy days and on dry days. Each day he added another observation statement to his list. Finally, his induetivist conscience was satisfied and he carried out an inductive inference to conclude: "I am always fed at 9 a.m." Alas, this conclusion was shown to be false in no uncertain manner when, on Christmas Eve, instead of being fed, he had his throat cut. An inductive inference with true premises had led to a false conclusion. Fortunately, modern medicine has abandoned this naive form of inductivism and we can claim that the real progress of the last one hundred years has been in no small part due to the emergence of hypotheticodeductivism, falsificationism and the "research programmes" of Imre Lakatos. Michael Baum, FRACS Department of Surgery. The Rayne Institute 123 Coldharbour Lane, London, SE5 9NU t. Chalmer AF. What is this thing called science? Milton Keynes: Open University Press, 1988. Sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS) and environmental temperature To the Editor: Dr Murphy has made the important observation that in Australia' as well as Britain' infants at the upper end of the SIDS age range are more likely to die about six days after a fall in outside temperature. Dr Hassall' is surely right to suggest that the link lies in behaviour rather than infection, and I would like to propose that the explanation may be as follows. When the weather gets very cold mothers keep their babies warmer, by increasing the bedroom heating or putting on more bedclothes, or both. The outside temperature may then rise again, but there is a lag before the mother readjusts the heating and bedding, so that for a while the baby may be kept much warmer than usual. In exceptional circumstances, if the baby then contracts a fever, or gets totally covered by his bedding, he may become so hot that he expires, possibly through apnoea. This is of course unproven, but there is an increasing amount of suggestive evidence. Mothers have been shown to put on more bedding in response to outside rather than room temperature." SIDS victims may be soaked in sweat' and have a high rectal temperature long after death.' They are more likely to have slept in the prone position.t-" in which heat loss is less and submergence under bedclothes more likely. They are likely to have higher insulation than other babies," to be found totally covered by a duvet (unpublished observations) or to be in an unusually warm environment. '0There is often evidence, either from the history or at autopsy, of minor infection, II particularly in babies at the upper end of the SIOS age range. This hypothesis is unlikely to account for more than a fraction of SIDS cases, but the proportion may be significant enough to explain Dr Murphy's findings. Christopher Bacon, FRCP Friarage Hospital Northallerton, North Yorkshire DL6 IJG, UK I. Campbell MJ. Sudden infant death syndrome and environmental temperature: further evidence for a time-lagged relationship. Med J Aust 1989; lSI: 36S·367. 2. Murphy MfG, Campbell MJ. Sudden infant death syndrome and environmental temperature: an analysis using vital statistics. J Epidemiol Community Health 1987; 41: 63·71. 3. Hassall lB. Sudden infant death syndrome the "ANZ factor". Med J Aust 1989; lSI: 361. 4. Nicoll A. Davies L. How warm are babies kept at home? Health Visitor 1986; S9: 113·114. S. Kahn A, Blum D. Sudden infant death syndrome and phenothiazines. Pediatrics 1983; 71: 987·988. 6. Sunderland R, Emery JL. Febrile convulsions and cot death. Lancet 1987; 2: 176-178. 7. Nelson EAS, Taylor BJ, WeatheralllC. Sleeping position and infant bedding may predispose to hyperthermia and the sudden infant death syndrome. Lancet 1989; 1: 199·201. 8. de Jonge GA, Engelberts AC, Koomen-Liefting AJM, Kotense PJ. Cot death and sleeping position in The Netherlands. Br Med J 1989; 298: 722. 9. fleming PJ, et al. The interaction between bedding and sleeping position in sudden infant death syndrome: a population-based controlled study. Br Med J (in press). 10. Bass M, Kravath RE, Glass L. Death scene investigation in sudden infant death. N Engl J Med 1986; 31S: lOO-IOS. II. Stanton AN, et aI. Terminal symptoms in children dying suddenly and unexpectedly at home. Br Med J 1978; 2: 1249-12SI.