Abstract:Inconsistent peak picking outcomes are a critical concern in processing liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS)-based untargeted metabolomics data. This work systematically studied the mechanisms behind the discrepancies among five commonly used peak picking algorithms, including CentWave in XCMS, linear-weighted moving average in MS-DIAL, automated data analysis pipeline (ADAP) in MZmine 2, Savitzky-Golay in El-MAVEN, and FeatureFinderMetabo in OpenMS. We first collected 10 public metabolomics datasets representing various LC-MS analytical conditions. We then incorporated several novel strategies to (i) acquire the optimal peak picking parameters of each algorithm for a fair comparison, (ii) automatically recognize false metabolic features with poor chromatographic peak shapes, and (iii) evaluate the real metabolic features that are missed by the algorithms. By applying these strategies, we compared the true, false, and undetected metabolic features in each data processing outcome. Our results show that linear-weighted moving average consistently outperforms the other peak picking algorithms. To facilitate a mechanistic understanding of the differences, we proposed six peak attributes: ideal slope, sharpness, peak height, mass deviation, peak width, and scan number. We also developed an R program to automatically measure these attributes for detected and undetected true metabolic features. From the results of the 10 datasets, we concluded that four peak attributes, including ideal slope, scan number, peak width, and mass deviation, are critical for the detectability of a peak. For instance, the focus on ideal slope critically hinders the extraction of true metabolic features with low ideal slope scores in linear-weighted moving average, Savitzky-Golay, and ADAP. The relationships between peak picking algorithms and peak attributes were also visualized in a principal component analysis biplot. Overall, the clear comparison and explanation of the differences between peak picking algorithms can lead to the design of better peak picking strategies in the future.

PICKY: a novel SVD-based NMR spectra peak picking method

DEEP picker is a deep neural network for accurate deconvolution of complex two-dimensional NMR spectra

A Novel Spectral Library Workflow to Enhance Protein Identifications

DEEP Picker1D and Voigt Fitter1D: a versatile tool set for the automated quantitative spectral deconvolution of complex 1D-NMR spectra

SparseCodePicking: feature extraction in mass spectrometry using sparse coding algorithms

Scaled Alternating Steepest Descent Algorithm Applied for Protein Structure Determination from Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Data.

Efficiently driving protein-based fragment screening and lead discovery using two-dimensional NMR

HSQCid: A Powerful Tool for Paving the Way to High-throughput Structural Dereplication of Natural Products Based on Fast NMR Experiments

PINE-SPARKY.2 for automated NMR-based protein structure research

A new method on reconstructing protein structure from NOESY distances

Peptide Selection for Accurate Targeted Protein Quantification Via a Dimethylation High-Resolution Mass Spectrum Strategy with a Peptide Release Kinetic Model

PeakBot: machine-learning-based chromatographic peak picking

PISV: A Novel Algorithm for Peptide Identification Using Spectrum Vector

DeepETPicker: Fast and accurate 3D particle picking for cryo-electron tomography using weakly supervised deep learning

PeakSelect: Preprocessing Tandem Mass Spectra for Better Peptide Identification.

Mechanistic Understanding of the Discrepancies between Common Peak Picking Algorithms in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry-Based Metabolomics

ASAP: An automatic sequential assignment program for congested multidimensional solid state NMR spectra

Developing a Peak Extraction and Retention (PEER) Algorithm for Improving the Temporal Resolution of Raman Spectroscopy

Data-Driven Tool for Cross-Run Ion Selection and Peak-Picking in Quantitative Proteomics with Data-Independent Acquisition LC-MS/MS

XCloud-VIP: Virtual Peak Enables Highly Accelerated NMR Spectroscopy and Faithful Quantitative Measures

MPicker: Visualizing and Picking Membrane Proteins for Cryo-Electron Tomography