Calcification Rates in Corals

D. B. Carlon,T. Goreau,N. Goreau,R. Trench,R. Hayes,A. Marshall
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.274.5284.117
IF: 56.9
1996-10-04
Science
Abstract:The report "Calcification in hermatypic and ahermatypic corals" by A. T. Marshall (2 Feb., p. 637) sheds light on the poorly understood relationship between photosynthesis and calcification in reef corals, but it does not provide a strong test of whether calcification proceeds at higher rates in hermatypic (reef-building) species compared with that in ahermatypic species. This hypothesis, if true, would validate the pivotal role of coral-algal symbiosis in the development of coral reefs in tropical waters. There are two reasons why I am not convinced. First, as Goreau and Goreau (1) and others have found, calcification rates can vary by as much as a factor of 10 between hermatypic species. Thus, hypotheses concerning calcification rates in hermatypic and ahermatypic corals are dealing with statistical phenomena and therefore require a sample size greater than one. Second, the use of the term (Marshall's included) "reef-building coral" is problematic. While all hermatypic corals are termed "reef-building," it is unlikely that all hermatypic corals make significant contributions to the construction of coral reefs. The steps between organismal-level calcification and the incorporation of this material in reef growth are complex (2) and poorly understood. However, a few species (that is, framework species) may make disproportionate contributions to reef accretion. Marshall says he chose the hermatype Galaxea fascicularis for his experiments because it has polyps of a size similar to those of the ahermatype Tubastrea faulkneri. It would also be useful to compare calcification rates in known framework species and in ahermatypes. David B. Carlon Department of Soil and Environmental Sciences, 2208 Geology Building, University of California, Riverside, CA 92521-0424, USA E-mail: dcarlon@citrus.ucr.edu
What problem does this paper attempt to address?