Abstract:To study users' travel behaviour and travel time between origin and destination, researchers employ travel surveys. Although there is consensus in the field about the potential, after over ten years of research and field experimentation, Smartphone-based travel surveys still did not take off to a large scale. Here, computer intelligence algorithms take the role that operators have in Traditional Travel Surveys; since we train each algorithm on data, performances rest on the data quality, thus on the ground truth. Inaccurate validations affect negatively: labels, algorithms' training, travel diaries precision, and therefore data validation, within a very critical loop. Interestingly, boundaries are proven burdensome to push even for Machine Learning methods. To support optimal investment decisions for practitioners, we expose the drivers they should consider when assessing what they need against what they get. This paper highlights and examines the critical aspects of the underlying research and provides some recommendations: (i) from the device perspective, on the main physical limitations; (ii) from the application perspective, the methodological framework deployed for the automatic generation of travel diaries; (iii)from the ground truth perspective, the relationship between user interaction, methods, and data.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: how to use smartphone data to mine users' travel behaviors in order to replace or supplement traditional travel surveys (Traditional Travel Surveys, TTS). Although smartphone - based travel surveys (Smartphone - based Travel Surveys, SBTS) have great potential technically, their large - scale application still faces many challenges. Specifically, this paper explores the following aspects: 1. **Limitations of traditional travel surveys**: - Traditional travel surveys rely on manual interviews and have problems such as missing short - distance trips and being unable to capture changes in user behaviors. - Traditional surveys usually only focus on data from a single day and it is difficult to reflect users' long - term behavior patterns. 2. **Advantages and challenges of smartphone - based travel surveys**: - Smartphones can passively collect a large amount of high - resolution data, such as location, time and other information, so as to understand users' travel behaviors more comprehensively. - However, SBTS faces problems such as data quality, privacy protection, and insufficient user participation. 3. **The role of machine learning in SBTS**: - Machine learning algorithms play an important role in SBTS and are used for tasks such as automatically generating travel diaries, detecting travel patterns and purposes, and matching maps. - The performance of machine learning models depends on high - quality training data (i.e., "ground truth"), and the quality of these data depends on users' verification and correction. 4. **Key issues and challenges**: - **Data quality issues**: Inaccurate labels will affect algorithm training and the accuracy of travel diaries, forming a vicious cycle. - **Privacy issues**: GPS trajectory data involves users' privacy. How to protect users' privacy while ensuring data quality is an important topic. - **User interaction design**: Whether the design of the user interface is simple and intuitive directly affects the effect of users' correction of wrong predictions, and further affects data quality. - **Device performance and battery life**: Using sensors for a long time and complex computing models will consume a large amount of power. How to optimize these problems is also the focus of research. By solving the above problems, this paper aims to provide guidance for practitioners, help them evaluate the feasibility and potential advantages of SBTS, and put forward improvement suggestions.

Mining User Behaviour from Smartphone data: a literature review

Analysis and Applications of Smartphone User Mobility

Comprehensive Review of Travel Behavior and Mobility Pattern Studies That Used Mobile Phone Data

GPS-supported smartphone app-based integrated travel diary and time-use data collection: challenges and lessons learned

Spatio-Temporal Routine Mining on Mobile Phone Data

Learning from user behavior: A survey-assist algorithm for longitudinal mobility data collection

The Smartphone-Based Person Travel Survey System: Data Collection, Trip Extraction, and Travel Mode Detection

From Taxi Gps Traces to Social and Community Dynamics: A Survey

Urban Sensing based on Mobile Phone Data: Approaches, Applications and Challenges

Trip Purposes Mining From Mobile Signaling Data

Mining Smart Card Data for Travelers' Mini Activities

Design and Implementation of a Smartphone-Based Travel Survey

Mining Travel Patterns from GPS-Tagged Photos

Methodology for Mining, Discovering and Analyzing Semantic Human Mobility Behaviors

Mining Tourism Experience on Twitter: A case study

Investigation on the Spatio-Temporal Mobility and Smartphone Usage of College Students.

Mining urban lifestyles: urban computing, human behavior and recommender systems

Knowing Your Population: Privacy-Sensitive Mining of Massive Data

Activity recognition for a smartphone and web based travel survey

Mining Usage Data from Large-Scale Android Users: Challenges and Opportunities.

Research Issues in Mining User Behavioral Rules for Context-Aware Intelligent Mobile Applications