Lipid exchange enhances geometric pinning in multicomponent membranes on patterned substrates

Melissa Rinaldin,Piermarco Fonda,Luca Giomi,Daniela J. Kraft

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/C9SM02393C

2019-12-05

Abstract:Experiments on supported lipid bilayers featuring liquid ordered/disordered domains have shown that the spatial arrangement of the lipid domains and their chemical composition are strongly affected by the curvature of the substrate. Furthermore, theoretical predictions suggest that both these effects are intimately related with the closed topology of the bilayer. In this work, we test this hypothesis by fabricating supported membranes consisting of colloidal particles of various shapes lying on a flat substrate. A single lipid bilayer coats both colloids and substrate, allowing local lipid exchange between them, thus rendering the system thermodynamically open, i.e. able to exchange heat and molecules with an external reservoir in the neighborhood of the colloid. By reconstructing the Gibbs phase diagram for this system, we demonstrate that the free-energy landscape is directly influenced by the geometry of the colloid. In addition, we find that local lipid exchange enhances the pinning of the liquid disordered phase in highly curved regions. This allows us to provide estimates of the bending moduli difference of the domains. Finally, by combining experimental and numerical data, we forecast the outcome of possible experiments on catenoidal and conical necks and show that these geometries could greatly improve the precision of the current estimates of the bending moduli.

Soft Condensed Matter

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how lipid exchange affects the geometric pinning phenomenon in multi - component lipid membranes. Specifically, the researchers focused on how the spatial arrangement and chemical composition of the liquid - ordered (LO) and liquid - disordered (LD) phase domains in supported lipid bilayers on patterned substrates with colloidal particles of different shapes (such as spherical, dumbbell - shaped, cubic, etc.) are affected by the substrate curvature. In addition, they also explored the relationship between these effects and the bilayer - closing topological structure, and experimentally verified the theoretical prediction of whether local lipid exchange can enhance the geometric pinning phenomenon while suppressing the antimixing phenomenon.

### Main research questions:
1. **Effect of lipid exchange on geometric pinning**: By constructing a supported - membrane system on a patterned substrate containing colloidal particles of different shapes, the researchers explored how lipid exchange affects the geometric pinning phenomenon of the LD phase in high - curvature regions.
2. **Suppression of the antimixing phenomenon**: The researchers also tested whether lipid exchange can suppress the antimixing phenomenon in an open system, that is, although the lipids are mixed, they are strongly partitioned into regions of different curvatures.
3. **Estimation of the bending modulus**: By combining experimental and numerical data, the researchers attempted to estimate the difference in the bending modulus between the LO and LD phases and predict the experimental results on other geometric shapes (such as cat - ene necks and conical necks).

### Research background:
- **Multi - component artificial lipid membranes**: A ternary mixture composed of cholesterol and phospholipids will undergo liquid - liquid phase separation under specific temperatures and lipid chemical compositions to form LO and LD phases.
- **Characteristics of LO and LD phases**: The LO phase is rich in saturated lipids and cholesterol, is thicker and less bendable; the LD phase is rich in unsaturated lipids, is thinner and more easily bent.
- **Geometric pinning phenomenon**: Experiments have shown that the LD phase tends to be located in regions of high mean curvature, while the LO phase avoids regions of high negative Gaussian curvature.
- **Antimixing phenomenon**: In a closed system, even if the lipids are mixed, they will be strongly partitioned into regions of different curvatures.

### Experimental design:
- **Substrates and colloidal particles**: Patterned substrates were constructed using colloidal particles of different shapes (such as spherical, dumbbell - shaped, cubic).
- **Preparation of lipid bilayers**: Multi - component lipid bilayers were formed by depositing small unilamellar vesicles (SUVs) on the substrates.
- **Lipid exchange**: One part of the membrane is attached to the colloidal particles, and the other part is attached to the flat substrate, forming an open system that allows lipid exchange.

### Results and discussion:
- **Enhancement of geometric pinning**: The experimental results showed that local lipid exchange significantly enhanced the geometric pinning phenomenon of the LD phase in high - curvature regions.
- **Suppression of antimixing**: Lipid exchange also suppressed the antimixing phenomenon, making the lipids more evenly distributed on the membrane.
- **Estimation of the bending modulus**: By analyzing the experimental data, the researchers estimated the difference in the bending modulus between the LO and LD phases and predicted the experimental results on other geometric shapes.

### Conclusion:
This study experimentally demonstrated the importance of local lipid exchange in multi - component lipid membranes. It not only enhanced the geometric pinning phenomenon but also suppressed the antimixing phenomenon. These findings are of great significance for understanding the dynamic behavior of cell membranes and for developing new biosensors and drug - delivery systems.