Abstract:Topic models are widely used unsupervised models capable of learning topics - weighted lists of words and documents - from large collections of text documents. When topic models are used for discovery of topics in text collections, a question that arises naturally is how well the model-induced topics correspond to topics of interest to the analyst. In this paper we revisit and extend a so far neglected approach to topic model evaluation based on measuring topic coverage - computationally matching model topics with a set of reference topics that models are expected to uncover. The approach is well suited for analyzing models' performance in topic discovery and for large-scale analysis of both topic models and measures of model quality. We propose new measures of coverage and evaluate, in a series of experiments, different types of topic models on two distinct text domains for which interest for topic discovery exists. The experiments include evaluation of model quality, analysis of coverage of distinct topic categories, and the analysis of the relationship between coverage and other methods of topic model evaluation. The paper contributes a new supervised measure of coverage, and the first unsupervised measure of coverage. The supervised measure achieves topic matching accuracy close to human agreement. The unsupervised measure correlates highly with the supervised one (Spearman's $\rho \geq 0.95$). Other contributions include insights into both topic models and different methods of model evaluation, and the datasets and code for facilitating future research on topic coverage.

A Coefficient of Determination for Probabilistic Topic Models

Incorporating Probabilistic Knowledge into Topic Models.

Relative Synergy Coefficient: A Novel Way to Detect Variable Interaction in Large Dataset

Coefficients of Determination for Mixed-Effects Models

Evaluating Topic Quality with Posterior Variability

Reliability of Topic Modeling

A Topic Coverage Approach to Evaluation of Topic Models

Collaborative Topic Regression for Online Recommender Systems: an Online and Bayesian Approach

Probabilistic Non-Negative Matrix Factorization and Its Robust Extensions for Topic Modeling.

Probabilistic Topic Modeling for Comparative Analysis of Document Collections

R-squared for Bayesian Regression Models

Authorship attribution based on a probabilistic topic model

Topic representation: finding more representative words in topic models

Can Topic Models Be Used in Research Evaluations? Reproducibility, Validity, and Reliability when Compared with Semantic Maps

Coefficients of factor score determinacy for mean plausible values of Bayesian factor analysis

A Topic Modeling Approach to Ranking

A Bayesian Topic Model for Human-Evaluated Interpretability.

Determination of the Number of Topics Intrinsically: Is It Possible?

Is Automated Topic Model Evaluation Broken?: The Incoherence of Coherence

Entry-Wise Eigenvector Analysis and Improved Rates for Topic Modeling on Short Documents