SDSS-IV MaNGA: Bar pattern speed estimates with the Tremaine-Weinberg method and their error sources

L. Garma-Oehmichen,M. Cano-Díaz,H. Hernández-Toledo,E. Aquino-Ortíz,O. Valenzuela,J. A. L. Aguerri,S. F. Sánchez,M. Merrifield

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stz3101

2019-11-01

Abstract:Estimating the bar pattern speed (\Om{}) is one of the main challenges faced in understanding the role of stellar bars in galaxy dynamical evolution. This work aims to characterise different uncertainty sources affecting the Tremaine Weinberg (TW)-method to study the correlation between bar and galaxies physical parameters. We use a sample of 15 MaNGA SDSS-IV galaxies and 3 CALIFA galaxies from \cite{Aguerri2015}. We studied the errors related with (i) galaxy centre determination, (ii) disc position angle (PA) emphasising the difficulties triggered by outer non-axisymmetric structures besides the bar, (iii) the slits length and (iv) the spatial resolution. In average, the PA uncertainties range $\sim 15 \%$, the slit length $\sim 9 \%$ and the centring error $\sim 5 \%$. Reducing the spatial resolution increases the sensitivity to the PA error. Through Monte Carlo simulations, we estimate the probability distribution of the \R{} bar speed parameter. The present sample is composed of 7 slow, 4 fast and 7 ultrafast bars, with no trend with morphological types. Although uncertainties and low sample numbers may mask potential correlations between physical properties, we present a discussion of them: We observe an anti-correlation of \Om{} with the bar length and the stellar mass, suggesting that massive galaxies tend to host longer and slower bars. We also observe a correlation of the molecular gas fraction with \R{}, and a weak anti-correlation with \Om{}, suggesting that bars rotate slower in gaseous discs. Confirmation of such trends awaits future studies.

Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problems that this paper attempts to solve are different sources of uncertainty in estimating the galactic bar pattern speed ($\Omega_{\text{bar}}$), especially using the Tremaine - Weinberg (TW) method to study the correlations between bars and galactic physical parameters. Specifically, the author focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Error in center determination**: The influence of the determination of the galactic center on the measurement results.
2. **Error in disk position angle (PA)**: Especially the difficulties caused by external non - axisymmetric structures (such as structures other than bars).
3. **Error in slit length**: The influence of different slit lengths on the measurement results.
4. **Error in spatial resolution**: The sensitivity of the measurement results to the change in spatial resolution.

Through these studies, the author hopes to better understand the applicability and limitations of the TW method in actual observations and provide more accurate methodological support for future measurements. In addition, the author also explores the potential correlations between $\Omega_{\text{bar}}$ and physical properties such as bar length, stellar mass, and molecular gas fraction. Although the sample size is limited, the preliminary results show some interesting trends, for example:

- $\Omega_{\text{bar}}$ is negatively correlated with bar length and stellar mass, indicating that more massive galaxies tend to have longer and more slowly rotating bars.
- The molecular gas fraction is weakly negatively correlated with $\Omega_{\text{bar}}$, indicating that bars in gas - rich disks rotate more slowly.

These findings provide an important reference for further research, but more data are still needed to confirm these trends.