Limits to surface-enhanced Raman scattering near arbitrary-shape scatterers

Jérôme Michon,Mohammed Benzaouia,Wenjie Yao,Owen D. Miller,Steven G. Johnson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1364/OE.27.035189

2019-08-31

Abstract:The low efficiency of Raman spectroscopy can be overcome by placing the active molecules in the vicinity of scatterers, typically rough surfaces or nanostructures with various shapes. This surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) leads to substantial enhancement that depends on the scatterer that is used. In this work, we find fundamental upper bounds on the Raman enhancement for arbitrary-shaped scatterers, depending only on its material constants and the separation distance from the molecule. According to our metric, silver is optimal in visible wavelengths while aluminum is better in the near-UV region. Our general analytical bound scales as the volume of the scatterer and the inverse sixth power of the distance to the active molecule. Numerical computations show that simple geometries fall short of the bounds, suggesting further design opportunities for future improvement. For periodic scatterers, we use two formulations to discover different bounds, and the tighter of the two always must apply. Comparing these bounds suggests an optimal period depending on the volume of the scatterer.

Optics,Applied Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the theoretical upper limit of surface - enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) in scatterers of arbitrary shapes. Specifically, the author aims to find the maximum value of the enhancement degree of the Raman signal for scatterers of given materials and geometries. This research not only considers aperiodic structures but also explores the case of periodic structures, and derives the enhancement upper limit of periodic structures through two different methods, thereby finding the optimal period length. In addition, the paper also compares the gap between the actual performance of several common SERS structures and the theoretical upper limit, and points out the direction for future design optimization.

### Main research contents:
1. **Derivation of theoretical upper limit**: The paper first theoretically derives the upper limit of SERS enhancement, which only depends on material constants and the distance between molecules and scatterers. For scatterers of arbitrary shapes, the author finds a general analytical formula, which shows that the enhancement effect is proportional to the volume of the scatterer and inversely proportional to the sixth power of the distance from the molecule to the scatterer.

2. **Material selection**: According to the proposed metric, silver is the optimal material in the visible light band, while aluminum performs better in the near - ultraviolet region.

3. **Analysis of periodic structures**: For periodic structures, the author uses two different methods to derive the enhancement upper limit, and points out that under specific conditions, the enhancement effect of periodic structures can exceed that of a single scatterer. However, this enhancement effect is affected by the period length, and there is an optimal period length.

4. **Performance evaluation of actual structures**: Through numerical simulation, the author evaluates the actual performance of several common SERS structures (such as triangular prisms and spheres) and compares them with the theoretical upper limit. The results show that the performance of existing designs such as bow - tie antennas is far below the theoretical upper limit, which provides a direction for future optimization designs.

### Key conclusions:
- **Theoretical upper limit**: The paper successfully derives the theoretical upper limit of SERS enhancement, which is applicable to scatterers of arbitrary shapes.
- **Material selection**: Silver is the optimal material in the visible light band, and aluminum performs better in the near - ultraviolet region.
- **Periodic structures**: Periodic structures can achieve a higher enhancement effect under specific conditions, but there is an optimal period length.
- **Design optimization**: The performance of existing designs is far below the theoretical upper limit, and future designs can further improve the SERS enhancement effect by optimizing the shape and arrangement of scatterers.

### Formula summary:
- **Total efficiency of Raman enhancement**:
\[
q=\frac{\vert\alpha_R E\vert^2\rho_p}{\vert\alpha_R\vert^2\vert E_{\text{inc}}\vert^2\rho_b}
\]
where \(q\) is the total efficiency of Raman enhancement, \(\alpha_R\) is the Raman polarizability tensor, \(E\) is the total electric field, and \(\rho_p\) and \(\rho_b\) are the enhancement and background values of the local density of states (LDOS), respectively.

- **Upper limit of local field enhancement**:
\[
q_{\text{loc}}\leq\left(1 + \frac{\vert\chi\vert^2}{\text{Im}\chi}\|G U^* R\|\sqrt{V}\right)^2
\]
where \(q_{\text{loc}}\) is the local field enhancement, \(V\) is the volume of the scatterer, \(G\) is the Green function, and \(U^* R\) is the orthogonal basis of the Raman polarizability tensor.

- **Area - scaling upper limit of periodic structures**:
\[
q_{\text{loc}}\leq\frac{2S k^2\cos\theta}{3\pi n_b^4}\left[1+\frac{3\pi n_b^2}{2k^3}\frac{\vert\chi\vert^2}{\text{Im}\chi}\|G_{\text{per}} U^* R\|^2\right]
\]
where \(S\) is the surface area of the unit cell, \(k\) is the wave number, \(\theta\) is the polar angle, and \(n_b\) is the refractive index of the background medium.

These research results provide an important theoretical basis and foundation for the further optimization and development of SERS technology.