Comparison of wave-structure interaction dynamics of a submerged cylindrical point absorber with three degrees of freedom using potential flow and computational fluid dynamics models

Panagiotis Dafnakis,Amneet Pal Singh Bhalla,Sergej Antonello Sirigu,Mauro Bonfanti,Giovanni Bracco,Giuliana Mattiazzo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0022401

2020-10-27

Abstract:In this paper we compare the heave, surge, and pitch dynamics of a submerged cylindrical point absorber, simulated using potential flow and fully-resolved computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models. The potential flow model is based on the time-domain Cummins equation, whereas the CFD model uses the fictitious domain Brinkman penalization (FD/BP) technique. The submerged cylinder is tethered to the seabed using a power take-off (PTO) unit which restrains the heave, surge, and pitch motions of the converter, and absorbs energy from all three modes. It is demonstrated that the potential theory over-predicts the amplitudes of heave and surge motions, whereas it results in an insignificant pitch for a fully-submerged axisymmetric converter. It also under-estimates the slow drift of the buoy, which the CFD model is able to capture reliably. Further, we use fully-resolved CFD simulations to study the performance of a three degrees of freedom (DOF) cylindrical buoy under varying PTO coefficients, mass density of the buoy, and incoming wave heights. It is demonstrated that the PTO coefficients predicted by the linear potential theory are sub-optimal for waves of moderate and high steepness. The wave absorption efficiency improves significantly when higher than the predicted value of the PTO damping is selected. Simulations with different mass densities of the buoy show that converters with low mass densities have an increased tension in their PTO and mooring lines. Moreover, the mass density also influences the range of resonance periods of the device. Finally, simulations with different wave heights show that at higher heights, the wave absorption efficiency of the converter decreases and a large portion of available wave power remains unabsorbed.

Fluid Dynamics,Computational Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: comparing the use of potential flow theory and fully resolved Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) models to simulate the wave-structure interaction dynamics of a fully submerged cylindrical point absorber in three degrees of freedom (heave, sway, and pitch).

Specifically, the researchers aim to evaluate the accuracy of these two different numerical methods (potential flow model and CFD model) in predicting the dynamic behavior of the point absorber and wave energy absorption efficiency. They found that:

1. **Potential Flow Model**: This model is based on the time-domain Cummins equation. It overestimates the predictions for heave and sway dynamics, while the predictions for pitch motion are almost negligible. Additionally, the potential flow model fails to accurately capture the slow drift phenomenon of the buoy.
2. **CFD Model**: This model uses the fictitious domain Brinkman penalization technique (FD/BP) and can more accurately simulate the dynamic behavior of the buoy, particularly reliably capturing the slow drift phenomenon of the buoy.

Furthermore, the study explores the impact of different Power Take-Off (PTO) coefficients, buoy density, and incident wave height on wave energy absorption efficiency. The results indicate that under medium to high steepness wave conditions, the PTO damping coefficient predicted by linear potential flow theory is not the optimal choice, and higher PTO damping values can significantly improve wave energy absorption efficiency. Low-density buoys experience greater tension on the PTO and mooring lines, and their range of resonance periods is also affected. As wave height increases, wave energy absorption efficiency decreases, with a large amount of available wave energy not being absorbed.